Homebrew Transparency Portal Reveals Needlessly Blocked 'Pirate' Sites.
Homebrew Transparency Portal Reveals Needlessly Blocked 'Pirate' Sites.
As the wave of pirate site blocking spreads globally, some European countries show weakness in their execution.
You're viewing a single thread.
“Copyright holders who initiated the blocking are required to monitor the blocked websites to ensure they still meet the criteria for blocking. If the conditions are no longer met, they must inform the Clearing House, which then notifies the ISPs to lift the block,”
They have no incentive to monitor and unblock them, it would just be more work (and therefore cost them more) to do this. When the list of blocked sites isn't even public, there's no way for them to be held to account unless someone sets up a service to check - just like this student did.
Australia tried this in the early noughties I believe - running a non-public URL blacklist. After some parliamentary accountability and commmitees got it cracked open, they found that about 10% of the sites met the definition for inclusion, with the remainder being a grab-bag of things various politicians and bureaucrats didn't like.