2d ago

Lemmy vs Mbin vs PieFed

Basically, It would be nice to point out what those platforms are & what are their "Killer Features"

For anyone who wants a quick glance at which platform might be suitable

You're viewing part of a thread.

Show Context

53 comments

If it was a good light theme, I would agree with you, but the light theme it chose to show me was awful. It sounds like if someone logs in and chooses light theme, they get this.
(And again, Lemmy does the same: Of the pretty unappealing theme options, the default is one of the most unappealing ones. If I remember, it likes to color unimportant UI elements in GARISH bright green and orange colors which are borderline alarming compared with the muted colors of everything else. Why not just default to “darkly”, because that is one that looks okay? Who knows.)
I was even questioning myself, like “why am I complaining about the pushpin”, and then I looked again at my screenshot and the pushpin is the only solid dark contrasting thing anywhere in the whole article listing, which explains why I was looking at it first and wondering what the heck it “did” until I figured it out. It’s so bad.
- You made me go check, and the signed-out site on an incognito tab does autoselect my browser-default dark theme. It looks much better than the light, incidentally, and the highlight to the Fedi tutorial link makes more sense in this context and is clearly restricted to signed-out users as a call to action/promo thing.
  I don't necessarily think the light theme is as awful as you're claiming, and at a glance it definitely seems to be derived from Dark and not the othe way around. The more I look into it the less this seems like a universal problem with the UX in Mbin derivatives and more "the light theme has made some debatable color choices".
  
  If you press the cog in the top right corner you can choose between six different themes, as well as moving the sidebar around, text size, and a bunch of other tweaks. :)
  
  Yeah, but that's bad, though.
  Hypercustomization is way more of a hassle than a positive in most applications. I will take a couple of binary settings, I won't design the UI for you.
  My contention here is that the default UI for the *Bin is actually good.
  
  I personally like being able to easily change the colour theme, but it's of course entirely optional. Each to their own.
  
  Being able to customize everything and having the defaults not be shit would be great. Using the customization options, which are excellent, as an excuse for the defaults being shit doesn't fly. To me.

53 comments