‘Biden, Macron know what’s going on in India but won’t talk’
‘Biden, Macron know what’s going on in India but won’t talk’
From her New Delhi home, acclaimed Indian writer and activist talks about G20 summit and state of India’s minorities.
You're viewing a single thread.
Hmmmm Modi seems really popular to Indians and the Indian diaspora.
I don’t agree with Modi but if he is getting elected he is getting elected.
If the west stopped interacting with every questionable leader of a country we’d never interact with any country; including western ones.
I have no time to read the article, but I assume this is about violent oppression of minorities:
I don’t agree with Modi but if he is getting elected he is getting elected.
A certain infamous German shitstain in history was elected, too...
Which German?
You know which one. Austrians were considered (and most identified) as Germans before WW2. Insisting they weren't of German ethnicity is a historical revisionism.
I didn't mentioned the ethnicity, but he wasn't German.
What was his ethnicity then?
Irrelevant, I was clearly mentioning nationality.
You wrote "Which German?", how is that "clearly mentioning nationality"?
German means both ethnicity and nationality.
In any normal conversation it refers to nationality.
The context is Hitler, so why can't you infer that German is spoken of as an ethnicity?
He was Austrian.. but a little Goodwin law.
but a little Goodwin law.
Godwin, by the way.
The article talks about the potential for India to slide into fascism.
It is definitely something to be concerned about but the things Modi is doing (stoking attacks on Muslims) is marginally better than what the CCP are doing (forced reeducation camps).
The west is happy to turn a blind eye to China, Modi would have to do a lot worse for any reaction from the west.
right, except sometimes it's easier to impose conditions on certain countries than others. for example the US was able to get the previous Indian administration to sign a treaty ceding partial control of their arsenal to them, on threat of sanctions (if I recall correctly). as much as the US might want to do something like that with China, it wouldn't be anywhere near as easy to pull off.
this is just an example, I'm not attaching moral value to what occurred/occurs
I don’t disagree and it’s a reasonable point that we should try to influence countries when influence works.
I suppose the downside of trying this with India though is Modi pulls closer to Putin and Xi which would be a bad outcome.
@lemmington_steele @Custoslibera
Assuming Biden wants to do anything about the CCP or Modi.
These regimes are useful to US, extending neoliberalism in India and cheap manufacturing for US companies in China. A little bit of ethnonationalism has never been a concern to US foreign policy.
Compared to other regimes supported by the US, such as Saudi Arabia, both Modi and the CCP are quite liberal regimes.
I get the idea but is Saudi Arabia worse than China?
@NoneOfUrBusiness @alphacyberranger @Custoslibera @raspberriesareyummy @lemmington_steele
Yes, very much so. On so may levels. Treatment of women, invasion of Yemen, brutal judicial system, destruction of climate, sponsorship of terrorism...
Just one example https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_of_Jamal_Khashoggi
I’m no china apologist, but if you know anything about how Indians riot, thousands of people can be murdered in a very short period of time. I haven’t heard anything about death squads for Uyghurs. Just saying, if I had to choose between being violently murdered by a Hindu mob and being detained by commies, I’d take the latter.
Tyranny of the majority shouldn't be tolerated.
And Tyranny of the minority should be?
This person wants nobles.
This person made it through at least one education system without learning about the French Revolution. Learned enough to type that sentence, not enough to know how fucking dumb it is.