no, but for a long time Irish, Italians, Germans etc... weren't white, until they needed to increase the size of "whites" because there weren't enough WASPS to outnumber POC
You realize there are at least 15 different ethnicities currently in Africa, right? Then there are also dark tones from islands, Americas, and Asia in addition. Black is also just a concept. That's what all races are, demographic groups assigned to vague characteristics. You're not having a "gotcha" moment, you're having an aneurysm.
That's a borderline insult, and you reported them for misinformation when what they're saying is how it really was.
I think the confusion is they're talking about what really happened, and you're acting like they're saying it was right.
"White" was expanded in America to include Irish and Italians.
As they lost the majority, they'd let in more groups to maintain the majority. No one is saying that made logical sense, and those lines are arbitrary.
I'd like you to look at this comment thread. They made the outlandish claim that Black People are the majority of prisoners in the USA, and then when corrected they said to exclude every other minority except white and black, and then when they were corrected yet again because it was still wrong with their added stipulations they said White People are not a racial demographic but Black People are.
This isn't a discussion about the definition of white in historical contexts, this is that user Orrk making a wildly inaccurate claim and wanting to metaphorically die on that hill.