my main problem with the hitchhikers guide to the galaxy [Spoilers] [x-post from sciencefiction@lemmy.ml]
my main problem with the hitchhikers guide to the galaxy [Spoilers] [x-post from sciencefiction@lemmy.ml]
I just posted this on the science fiction community lemmy.ml link to post, hadn’t found this community yet.
OK, so first off, as the title says, there will be spoilers in here. So if you’re planning on reading it and haven’t yet already, please stop.
I read the series as a teenager and absolutely love them. Recently, I have taken the time to reread all five of them, and have to say I was slightly disappointed. I still thought that the writing was very amusing, the social commentary was good and the lightly touched philosophical discussions were good as well. My main problem concerns character development, or better said, the complete lack thereof in my opinion. I found that most disturbing into different aspects:
The lack of real, meaningful friendship between characters As an example, Arthur and Ford are supposed to be friends, but from the interaction in the book it seems more like they tolerate each other and don’t really appreciate each other’s presence or influence on their adventures. Every time they get out of touch, they don’t appear to feel sorry about it, and when they see each other again, they are extremely British about it. This also applies to the other characters in my opinion.
** the complete abandonment of the relationship between Arthur and Fenchurch** So, in the first three books, Arthur is like this maladjusted guy, who really doesn’t know what his place in the universe is. This also applies to his personal relationships. Then, he meets a woman that is presented as his soulmate, someone that finally understands him and respects/likes him the way he is. All of a sudden, she disappears into thin air, and she’s only mentioned one more time in the book series. Arthur seems happy to just make sandwiches and doesn’t seem to mourn this loss too much after the initial search. To me, this makes the character rather shallow. I appreciate the author was not trying to write a novel about love in space, or whatever, but still, it feels a bit lacking to me.
I will end my rant here, I am very curious as to your opinions on this matter. Do you feel like I’m just expecting too much from these books or do you tend to agree with these criticisms?
You're viewing a single thread.
As an example, Arthur and Ford are supposed to be friends, but from the interaction in the book, it seems more like they tolerate each other and don’t really appreciate each other’s presence or influence on their adventures. Every time they get out of touch, they don’t appear to feel sorry about it, and when they see each other again, they are extremely British about it. This also applies to the other characters in my opinion.
From the point of view of having lived 23 years in the UK: So what you're saying is that they're extremely close best friends who can hardly bear to be apart and get exceedingly emotional about it... in a very British way?
Arthur seems happy to just make sandwiches and doesn’t seem to mourn this loss too much after the initial search.
So you're saying he's British. He could be dying inside, and be expressing that by showing absolutely no sign of it and continuing to make sandwiches.
Yes, I'm exaggerating, but so was Adams, and the books were written at a time when this was if anything even more ingrained in British culture.
Also, these are light comedy books, and sci-fi on top of that, neither of which lends themselves to romance.
I've published a couple of novels (don't get excited - they've sold more than average, but the average novel only sells ~200 copies; I've sold in the 4 digits... low 4 digits...) and one reviewer complained the first one had too much romance. It had some tension. No dates, romantic moonlight walks, or even a quick stolen kiss. The second one had a kiss, and I keep wondering how angry that reviewer would've gotten about that. Point being that a certain segment of the key market demographics for sci-fi gets very irate if they have to endure anything resembling romance.
EDIT: Also, to it not having found this yet, just wait a few seconds and try the search button again, and repeat a couple of times if necessary. It usually shows up pretty quickly (but frankly the UI could do with better messaging on that...)