What's a decently fancy coffee that's still affordable and will be well received even by non-coffee snobs?
I have been making the occasional coworker a cup of aeropressed coffee with good reviews thus far. Being that it is shift work, most of my coworkers are used to drinking the reduced syrup of a pot that's been left on the burner too long (one coworker thanked me for leaving it for her!). Many don't even know coffee doesn't have to be bitter, although some are hardcore enough caffeine addicts that they know what good coffee is, they just get what they can day-to-day.
For Christmas I'm going to make one good cup of coffee for each employee working each shift. I'll normally take whatever light roast grounds I can get day-to-day (see above), but I wanna jazz this up a little extra.
My wishlist is:
Decent
Cheap enough to distribute among around 20-30 people
No super niche flavors that would be off-putting to a "layperson."
I would look up local roasters and see who sells 5lb bags (if I was making for 30 people it would be 2lbs of coffee so if they have 2lbs get that but no one near me sells that, so get a bean you like and use it for yourself for a while) just get their flagship bean.
Local gets you no shipping costs and no shipping time.
This is sage advice. Over the years I’ve come to realise that even a mediocre local roaster is always much, much better than anything from Starcunts or any of the other shitty retail beans.
Rio Grande Roasters Pinon 3 Lb. Bag Ground Coffee https://a.co/d/cQAtOI6 is phenomenal. It's super smooth, has a naturally light and subtle dark chocolate background note. This coffee has ruined bad coffee for so many people once they try it. I get "never knew coffee could be like this." Pretty often from people that try it.
Colectivo from Milwaukee. Best prices for really well sourced coffee. They are really a 3rd wave roaster with a starbucks-like cafe setup that allows them to sell much cheaper than others even though they are still sourcing really great single origins and small session roasting. I've tried em all and Colectivo takes the price:quality ratio hands down.
Their Brazil is super chocolatey and not bitter at all for folks who don't necessarily love coffee, but people who really do will still find interesting notes and appreciate how well it's roasted. a bit of acidity but no bitterness, full body but subtle notes, total crowd pleaser.
Colectivo is good but I wouldn't sleep on Stone Creek from Milwaukee. They retooled their cafes a decade ago to be less like Starbucks or Caribou and more of a geekier experience. Their selection is pretty baller, their educational programs are neat (https://www.stonecreekcoffee.com/public-classes/), and their devotion to sustainability is admirable, IMHO.
I cannot suggest a widely recommended brand as I don't have experience of anything I would recommend, however have you considered a medium to dark roast? Most people drinking coffee outside the speciality scene will be expecting a traditional Italian style coffee. This might not be what you are trying to go for but you might get some mileage out of it.
I’ll echo that finding a local roaster is always a good bet, but they can be pretty expensive in my experience. I’ve been really happy with Driftaway Coffee. They ship anywhere in the US (I think they're based in New York). They’re all about being transparent about the bean growers and roasters, going as far as to give a breakdown of how much they pay growers for each variety compared to other companies. They include a handy little index card with each variety that gives you useful info on the producers (tons of women-owned collectives, for example), their locale, tasting notes, and brewing recommendations. My collection of these little cards is slowly growing and gives me a cool history of all the different beans I’ve tried.
I’m a big fan of single origin beans, and you can find a huge variety there, but they've also got a lot of blends. If you start a subscription, they first send you an "Explorer's Box" which is a blind taste-test of five different bean types that you rate. They then calibrate your subscription based on what you liked. Such a cool concept.
As for price, you can get most beans for around $24 for a one pound bag or $38 for a two pound bag, roasted on or right before the day they ship. Their subscriptions are a little cheaper (I get three pounds a month for $48).
That all probably sounded like an ad, but I'm just a really happy customer.
I'm late to this, but really, for questions like these, you really need to state two things:
Roughly where you live. If I recommend something from Indonesia, and you live in the UK, that's not going to cut it, is it?
A hard number for a budget, cheap has different meanings to different people across income groups. Cheap to me as broke student in my 20s is different from me as a working adult in my 40s.