Skip Navigation
48 comments
  • you can't just write off anything you want. You only get to write off certain things, but at the end of the day, a tax write off is just a tax deduction for how much you need to pay, in the same way any normal person paying their taxes does. Just like with personal taxes, you can just reduce your tax liability down to 0 if you get enough deductions.

    Corporations obviously work differently than for a normal person, but the same basic principle applies.

    Edit: i suppose i should clarify - You can take deductions for investment losses. Normal people can even do this. What you're referring to would be a deduction along those lines, where you're "writing off" a loss on your taxes. If you invest $100 in stock, and sell when the value is $50, you took a $50 loss, and can deduct those loses from your tax burden, because you're required to pay taxes on 50 less dollars that year.

  • A tax write off is also called a tax deduction.

    So when you do your taxes and you need to pick between the standard deduction or itemized, that's picking if you want to write off the standard amount or try to find all the amounts that might apply to you.

    The deductions, or write offs, reduce your income for tax purposes. So if you have 50k in taxable income, a 10k deduction will mean you're only taxed on 40k.

    To get something you would call a discount, you would need a tax credit, which reduces the bill by some fixed amount.

    10k write off: 100k income becomes 90k, 20% taxes are 18k.
    10k credit: 100k income at 20% is 20k, less 10k credit is 10k is taxes.

    Movie studios do complicated accounting to make it so the business that collects the money for showing the movie is often not the one that made the movie.
    That means that often the movie is able to be described as a financial failure even though it made more money than it cost to produce.
    Usually this isn't done for tax purposes, because the IRS will generally get their cut regardless, since if the movie makes money, someone is collecting it.

    Entertainment often pays actors, writers and such royalties based on a proportion of profits. By manipulating which specific entity actually shows the profit, they can manipulate how much royalties they have to pay.

    • Expense, not deduction. If you profited $100k on the sake of your house but had to spend $50k on repairs, you’ve only made $50k. The write off is subtracting the related expenses from income in order to calculate the actual profit

    • Entertainment often pays actors, writers and such royalties based on a proportion of profits. By manipulating which specific entity actually shows the profit, they can manipulate how much royalties they have to pay.

      And it's probably closer to what's happening here. Probably something in their contracts state that certain financial obligations will be paid on the movie's release. But if the movie is never released they don't need to pay out.

      But it sounds bad to come out and say "our contracts say we can get out of paying people if we don't release the movie so we aren't releasing the movie" rather than saying "we aren't releasing the movie because we can write it off on our taxes."

      Sure in the past there were significant distribution costs in pressing out all those copies of a film and sending it out to theaters everywhere. Even direct to video has distribution costs. So "writing off" a movie to avoid paying those costs made sense when it was done in the past. But direct to streaming is basically just copying some files to a server, and a movie is basically guaranteed to recoup those costs. So the only reason to write off a movie and not release it is because of contract shenanigans.

  • Overly simplistic and assuming you are talking about the US: So you spent 80M making a movie but for whatever reason it never makes it out of production, you never see any return on this investment. But overall this year you made 100M from something else. When you do your taxes, you can "write off" this 80M spent as a loss, so you only have to pay taxes on the remaining 20 million. It doesn't deduct 80M from taxes owed.

    • hollywood accountants will inflate the internal markup for everything, shuffle some numbers around, and come up with a 300mil 'write off' across all the various corporate divisions and shit.

48 comments