SD Maid terminated from Play Store due to 'Stalkerware policy' (Reddit thread)
SD Maid terminated from Play Store due to 'Stalkerware policy'
This is ridiculous, and really a bad news for everyone as there's no way to talk with an human
Original source is unfortunately on reddit, which I can't link
The developer goes into the situation in a reddit thread.
I had got the same stalkerware policy. The problem was not the app itself but the description. In my case “friend” and “track” or “monitor” keyword can’t be used together.
If your app description includes “monitor” or “track”, don’t include any person related keywords such as “friend”, “people”, “human”. If not, google considers your app can monitor the somebody’s activity.
https://www.reddit.com/r/androiddev/comments/15xj0ow/devaccountterminatedafter12yearsfor/jx72w7h/
Google: Invests billions in AI language models
Also Google: can't understand words have different meanings
It's ridiculous how a well standing dev can just have an app removed with no warning or human investigation.
Welcome to the walled garden.
Google is the biggest stalker on the planet. Are they afraid of a little competition?
Stupid take to be honest, real people getting trafficked and stalked, domestic abuse victims being tracked for control by the abuser, and you think that's fine because google has that data about you even though nobody can use it so why shouldn't all apps be able to? Go to a women's shelter, touch grass.
This issue is far more nuanced. No it's not good Google has that data on you.
No it's not fair that automatons caused a small developer to have their entire amount destroyed without a proper review.
Both things can be true.
https://github.com/d4rken-org/sdmaid-se
There's also the new open source version that the developer has been building
I paid for that Pro through Playstore. There goes my purchase 😭
Idiot google policy banning a 12 year old account, which doesn't even violate its policy. Maybe something a human review could've helped to cross-check if it really needed a ban. Either way sucks for the dev.
Thanks for sharing! Per rule 5 in the sidebar, we ask that original sources be submitted instead. If you could kindly update the submission body and title, it would be greatly appreciated.
Original source: https://www.reddit.com/r/androiddev/comments/15xj0ow/dev_account_terminated_after_12_years_for/
Or libreddit mirror: https://libreddit.domain.glass/r/androiddev/comments/15xj0ow/dev_account_terminated_after_12_years_for/
I was under the impression that all of the so-called "cleaner" apps were to be avoided. I take this was one of the good ones?
Edit: re-read article, it sounds like it was one of the good ones.
Yes, unfortunately it was probably the only real cleaner on the store. Probably the google bot didn't like that it was using accessibility controls to delete the cache of all apps (a regular app can't do this without root, so it was simulating human action to browse app by app and click on "delete cache")
One of the good ones for many years. One of the few great rooted apps I’d paid for and would install after every fresh rom flash.
I can confirm this has been a really good app for rooted users for years, also FOSS.
It's just sad what Google did
Further to your edit, there is actually a newer version in development: https://github.com/d4rken-org/sdmaid-se.
I also installed it from that repository, but maybe without a mainstream way to make money it might mean the end of the app... they banned the dev altogether with no way to escalate to a human supervisor...
Hopefully the bot in charge of appeals will reverse this...
Hopefully they can manage to sort this out somehow but I'd personally be more than happy to purchase a Pro upgrade another way.
