I kinda get where he is coming from. As you said, there are examples of people being falsely accused, but I think they are generally in the minority. When I think about the risk/reward of Madison saying what she did, given the giant power imbalance, it just doesn't seem like lying about those things would be very beneficial
I don't really have any stake in any of this, so I'm hesitant to form any strong opinion on the matter either way.