1y ago

I've heard some schools are reintroducing it now, but that doesn't help those that never learned.

You're viewing a single thread.

425 comments

I don't remember people ever writing cursive like what I was taught growing up. People just self-servingly turbo-scribble some chicken-scratch and call it a day. The kid who can't read our B-movie elvish script isn't the one with literacy issues.
We either write within the ballpark of standardization, or we don't. I think kids should be required to put in as much effort into learning cursive, as people put into actually writing cursive. Which is to say, absolutely none at all.
(Sorry to people who actually write legible, clean cursive. I wish I got to read your output in the wild.)
- The thing is, it's easy to read good cursive. It's just another script. It took me 5 episodes of Last Exile to memorize the Greek equivalents to English letters so I could read all the text without looking up the translation guide. But when their writing looks like Jack Lew's signature, there's not a whole lot I can do to decipher it
  
  Yes but really only the artistically minded and those with great manual dexterity have even a slim chance of doing it well. The rest has to write letters hundreds of times while their classmates go to recess.
- feels like a lot of older people just use cursive as an excuse to cover up bad handwriting, because it's harder to tell when it's all squiggly in the first place
  like, there's a reason we don't write in fancy serif typefaces, that would result in most people's writing being even less legible than it already is.
- I used to have really legible, accurate cursive. Someone made me feel embarrassed for still using cursive in middle school, so I stopped using it.
  Now I can't remember cursive well enough to use it quickly, and my print looks like an elementary child did it. ALL CAPS print is a good way for me to make my print more legible
- turbo-scribble some chicken-scratch and call it a day
  But that's cursive, isn't it? I always considered cursive the script to be written when you just quickly need to write something down,being the style where the pen is raised the least, which happens to be the fastest way to write, at the cost of legibility. So cursive to me seems like the opposite of fancy.
  
  Well,my teachers at the least insisted that cursive must be written perfectly, or you had to write it again.
  As in, "rewrite the assignment because the arch on this lower case n is too high".
  
  I only had that in primary school, because it's important to have legible handwriting (so the teachers can properly grade you being one of the reasons), and it's easier to change behaviours early on in life before they become habits, but after that I never had anyone insist on or expect perfect handwriting.
  
  Cursive was taught separately from print. In elementary school an assignment wouldn't be accepted in print, and afterwards it wouldn't be accepted in cursive.
  
  The thing is that back in the day you were expected to hand write all of your college assignments and printing or typewriting were not allowed. Because of that, it took decades and decades for enough older educators to die before people could use a computer for homework.
  
  Right. Depending on how old you are, you may have or did have older relatives who wrote in impeccable cursive. My grandmother, for example, who was a high school teacher from the 1940s through to the 70s, wrote cursive that looked almost machine-made because it was so perfect. But they actually taught penmanship as its own subject back when she was a kid in the 1930s.
- You're just not old enough. Cursive was everywhere when I was a kid. They should still teach it to children because children learn language and writing easier than adults do. We should be able to read cursive. It is part of our language, and our history. Every old document is written in cursive. We shouldn't end up with a society that can't even read its original Constitution. That's just Idiocracy.
  
  Do you read old English?
  
  On a regular basis? No. Ever? Of course. Shakespeare is written in old English, the original translation of Homer's The Odyssey, and the King James Bible, to name a few things.
  
  Shakespeare is modern English with some old words. This is Old English.
  https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/43521/beowulf-old-english-version
  
  Thanks for the example and the correction.
  
  The King James Bible is pretty much modern English. Shakespeare too. They actually sort of standardized modern English. Old English, the language,not just English that is old, looks like Icelandic or weird German and is maybe 500 years older than that, give or take.
  Edit: Everyone who down voted your comment is dumb. Being willing to learn new things is a mark of high intelligence. Being grateful for the opportunity to learn is the sign of wisdom. Those who downvote you should instead emulate you. If we punish people for being happy to learn, they won't want to learn.
  
  I didn't know that. Thanks for the correction.
  
  We are all constantly learning. Thank you for participating in this group discussion.
  
  Look at you two fucking learning and being civil and shit.
  Love it. Appreciate you both.
  
  Hey up yours, pal <3
  
  Beowulf is old English. Shakespeare is nothing like old English.
  
  Who the fuck understands old english??
  
  People who need to or want to out of personal interest, just like it should be with cursive.
  
  I remember an English teacher when I was at school talking about how he was teaching Beowulf to A level students and that it was very difficult for him as well not just the students.
  
  Pretty much only scholars. JRR Tolkien did, for example. The Rohirrim in the LOTR trilogy basically speak a form of Mercian Old English, if I recall correctly.
  
  I grew up in a house with a rotary phone and a meticulously maintained phone book (written in cursive.) If I'm too young to have been able to reliable hone my cursive-parsing skills, what can we expect of younger generations?
  The Flynn effect suggests people are generally getting smarter, remembering things better, etc. Something is happening to cause younger generations to be generally better than their ancestors. IQ scores have their problems but it's still a hopeful sign.
  
  Different circles I guess then. Everyone I knew wrote in cursive when I was younger. Regarding your intelligence comment, it's not an intelligence issue, just an education and exposure issue. Learning cursive is easier than learning to write all-together, but if you're never taught, and you're not exposed to it, then you're probably not going to learn it. It's such a simple thing to learn that I don't understand the aversion everyone on this thread has towards it. It's pretty nice when you have to write a lot of text, like taking notes or journaling.
  
  The aversion in my case comes from seeing time being wasted on that when teachers could use it to teach much more useful things or making sure that kids learned everything else they've been taught.
  
  Language changes. Teaching an entire script to be able to read translated documents when there are practical skills that could be taught instead is silly.
  We don't teach old English anymore, even though there's a huge amount of our cultural history contained in it.
  We don't even teach people about the eras when we used to use "f" in place if "s", and that's right in the middle of the constitution.
  Can you read the original magna carta? America would not be unique amongst English speaking nations in having issues dealing with language drift.
  
  lol mixing up language with its orthography system. Classic error

425 comments