I think the camera size is getting out of hand on iPhone 15 Pro (iPhone 15 leaks)
I think the camera size is getting out of hand on iPhone 15 Pro (iPhone 15 leaks)
The camera size is already huge in iPhone 14 Pro that it doesn’t sit well on MagSafe Duo Charger wishing that they figured out a way to at least keep the size to how it currently is but it looks like there’s no getting around it. It looks like it’s gonna be bigger than 45mm Apple Watch at this point.
You're viewing a single thread.
I just don’t understand why they don’t just make the phone thicker and have a flush camera. Does it really make such a difference?
The 14P (~200g, if I remember correctly, feels even heavier) is one of the heaviest phones I ever owned, especially compared to my 12 before it, but even compared to my Xs, which already felt heavy at the time. In the past I always agreed with statements of „just make the phone thicker“ for more battery, or to hide the bump. But with the 14P I cannot agree: just make the bump smaller an reduce weight.
I actually disagree there. Might be showing why I don’t work in high end product design lol, but I think as a pro model you can go a little crazy on the weight. You can probably save some thickness from under the camera bump somehow if you redistribute whatever can be displaced from under there, which would be easier in a thicker phone. Like any PCB that doesn’t need to be directly under the optoelectronics could be redesigned to go around some of the camera stuff, which would eat into the battery. But that wouldn’t be a problem when the whole thing is a mm or two thicker. 220g is probably not crazy. 250g would be pushing it. 300g would be unreasonable unless they have some real high tech stuff in there to show for it, like some kind of force touch or possibly a 3.5mm headphone connector.
The thing is heavy. I have a heavy case on it as well, go figure. I must admit though, in the past I used to drop my phone on my face. Now I make the split second effort to dodge if I drop it. But the weight makes it feel premium. Sure, the dad test is psychological, but that doesn’t mean it’s not important.
I think switching the back from all-glass to something else would help drop the weight slightly, but at this rate it’s just that there’s so much in these phones. Between the battery, the slabs of glass, the complicated cameras, you’d think fitting a headphone connector wouldn’t be so hard.
But that wouldn’t be a problem when the whole thing is a mm or two thicker. 220g is probably not crazy. 250g would be pushing it. 300g would be unreasonable
If they filled that space with battery, it'd probably be closer to 400g. Batteries are very heavy.
Battery size is obviously a compromise. Apple would have tested larger and smaller batteries, and come to the conclusion that the current size is perfect. They might change their mind, since battery life largely depends on what apps the user runs and trends change over time, but they would't be far off the mark.
I think switching the back from all-glass to something else
"Something else" would need to be non-conductive (to be compatible with wireless charging) and easily recycled (to meet their environmental commitments). Glass is probably the best option.
Also - glass isn't as heavy as you seem to think. Plastic is only lighter than glass if it's really thin, and thin plastic is too bendy. The back has to be stiff enough to stop the phone from bending, otherwise the screen will crack... plastic would be very thick (and very heavy) to achieve that.
The early model iPhones with a plastic back all had steel reinforced plastic backs. Steel is heavier than glass. And it blocks wireless charging.
I mean I agree about not making it thicker to flatten the back, but I have to disagree about making the camera smaller (if that means a sacrifice to quality. This is specifically a pro phone. Now admittedly, it’s not just for professionals and whether it deserves that name is up for debate. But the fact is, this is specifically meant to be the best. So imo, if you want something lighter, buy the lighter non-pro
Yeah, I see your point: I want the best camera on the go, therefore I buy Pro, but then complain about weight. Human nature I suppose 😂
So imo, if you want something lighter, buy the lighter non-pro
I'd argue being lighter is a feature, and one that I'd personally be happy to pay a premium for. The original MacBook Air was something like a thousand dollars more expensive than the MacBook for example (and I bought/loved that MacBook Air).
For example professional bicycles are usually hand laid carbon fibre. It costs a fortune and it's worse than a metal frame in every way (except weight), but people still pay for it, because weight matters.
And you’re absolutely correct. Being light is a feature. It’s a feature of the non-pro. The fact is, putting more, better components in will make the phone heavier. And the point of the pro is to have more features and be the better phone. Unlike a racing bicycle which very specifically has to be light. And also unlike the MacBook Air which again, the entire purpose of which was to be thin and light. I completely agree that being light is a feature, just not here.
I bought a 13 mini cause it’s basically the same size as the 4 I had and loved many years ago. The one thing I HATE is the camera sticking out, it ruins the entire sleek aesthetic of the phone
What a genuinely awful idea lol.
Why is it awful?
What would you fill all that extra space with?
Empty air? How is having empty air inside the phone better than having empty air outside the phone?
A larger battery? So you can charge every second day instead of every day? I don't think that'd be an improvement, it would almost certainly result in forgetting to charge your phone and you'd be more likely to have it go flat on you. Also batteries are extremely heavy.
A silicone protective coating? Also known as a phone case. This is really the only one that makes sense, and you can already do it.
Bro how tf would a bigger battery result in it dying more often? What u smoking and where can I find
If you don't need to charge your iPhone ever night, then you won't charge it every night. And sometimes you'll forget to charge it two nights in a row, and then your battery won't last the day.
Instead of one small part of the phone being slightly thicker, a part where you hand doesn’t even touch and it genuinely doesn’t matter, you’d rather the entire phone be thicker, making it take up more space in you hand and pocket. Then you’d have to do something with all this extra space you’ve wasted, so the phone will have to get heavier and use more materials to make.
And in return for worse ergonomics, cost, space efficiency, and overall aesthetics, all we get is a… smooth back? Which amounts to an ARGUABLY improved different aesthetic that affects less of the overall design than the thickness does? That sounds like the worst trade deal in the history of trade deals. That’s like putting square tires on a Jeep because it arguably matches the overall shape of the vehicle lol. Especially since most people have cases on their phones which could easily make up for the difference in thickness anyway.
This would also allow for a much larger battery
But i do think some would mind. A lot of people care about the overall look..?
And the weight.