Skip Navigation

You're viewing a single thread.

38 comments
  • I'm pretty sure most people don't want it to...

    • There's something like 50 million Threads users. Chances are there's at least a few people out there who would be happy to be able to connect with at least some of those 50 million people, without having to use Threads themselves.

      As an academic, I would just be happy if I could reach my peers on Mastodon. I don't really give a fuck which platform they choose to use - I've chosen mine, and that's enough for me.

      Furthermore, what's even the point of open standards if you don't want them to be adopted.

      • @sab If Threads plays by the rules, they're welcome, but if they fail to meet our moderation standards (as they likely will), we shouldn't give them any special treatment.

        Also, federating with Threads might not be as big a prospect as we originally thought. Daily active users had fallen by 80% last summer when Meta stopped releasing official numbers. It could be that the numbers have improved since, but then why not make a big deal over it?

      • Furthermore, what's even the point of open standards if you don't want them to be adopted.

        Well, yes. There does seem to be a lot of "we want open standards but we don't want big companies to use them" among fediverse users.

      • @sab

        "Furthermore, what's even the point of open standards if you don't want them to be adopted"

        JFC

        Didn't I reply to exactly this point somewhere else yesterday?

        Here:

        "Using "open protocols/standards" does not translate to "accept any content from anywhere"

        It's just like "Free Speech"

        You can say any damn thing you want, but I am under no obligation whatsoever to read or listen to anything you say

        Right?"

        Nor does it require any sysadmin to accept any content from anywhere

        cc @0x1C3B00DA @lemonflavoured

        • This makes no sense whatsoever. You could want Meta to use ActivityPub, say it's a good thing that they use an open standard, and still say you have no interest in communicating with them and stick to services where they are defederated.

          You don't have an obligation to read every email you receive just because it's an open standard.

          There's no logical connection between services using activitypub and you bring forced to connect to them. So I guess at least that's a point to your free speech example.

You've viewed 38 comments.