Skip Navigation

Dutch woman, 29, granted euthanasia approval on grounds of mental suffering

www.theguardian.com Dutch woman, 29, granted euthanasia approval on grounds of mental suffering

Zoraya ter Beek, who has chronic depression, anxiety, trauma and unspecified personality disorder, expected to end her life soon

Dutch woman, 29, granted euthanasia approval on grounds of mental suffering
237

You're viewing a single thread.

237 comments
  • My arguements against this are the same as my arguements against the death penalty.

    People make mistakes, even those who wish to die. Im not trusting the state with the power to kill me, even if its by assisted suicide.

    I only support this for people who are terminally ill and about to die.

    • I get where you're going but on the other side of your fear of the state you are denied release from what could be immense suffering because the state deems it.

      Body autonomy is in my opinion a very crucial part of human rights even if the decisions is ultimately a mistake. You can't really stop people from committing suicide, all you can do is make it less humane.

      • I get where you’re going but on the other side of your fear of the state you are denied release from what could be immense suffering because the state deems it.

        Often times its the state causing the immense suffering...

        Modern psychology really misses the mark in the sense often times its just treating the symptoms so they can get you back to work as quickly as possible.

        Im more interested in restorative justice with psychology, as well as treating the symptoms; we should be treating the causes too...

        Body autonomy is a myth, 'biopower' is a concept that has been utilized since the industrial age, the role of the structres of society are to keep you healthy enough to work.

        Regardless, I caveeted that yes, if you're physically about to die and under immense suffering id support these actions. In a privatesed health system with an aging demographic though you cannot prevent abuses of power from happening with assisted suicide; family members pressuring mentally ill family members into an early suicide to remove there care burden, people doing it for inheritance, people thinking they have a uncurable mental illness when in reality the effective treatments are denied to them (I think of PTSD war sufferers denied MDMA which is proven 90%+ effective in treating PTSD who go onto kill themselves...)

        There are so many ethical concerns with this stuff that only takes a little foresight to see how bad it would be in reality.

You've viewed 237 comments.