The most positive I've heard is that it is a by the numbers Bethesda rpg game. It doesn't try to be anything more. If you liked fallout 4 and skyrim odds are you'll like this.
They got rid of the dialogue wheel and went back to a list of options (influenced by character background / skills), so at least there's that, I suppose.
Then wait a few months and check some of the in-depth reviews before investing your time. Bethesda's most well known for its looter shooters with RPG styling.
I imagine this will follow in similar footsteps. It'll be well designed, well armed, but it's not going to be an RPG where your decisions have lasting impact. But hopefully I'm wrong
The only major gripe I have is how segmented the world is by fast travel.
You can't just wander around getting into trouble the same as you could in earlier Beth titles. You have to fast travel here, then fast travel there, oh and now you're done with this "dungeon"? Go fast travel here and there to get back to the city, then fast travel out to your next planet, then fast travel down to the surface.
Maybe that experience gets less abrasive over time, but I don't feel like it will.
One of it's strengths is the really detailed and interesting environments the game dumps you in early on. Starfield really does look and run great. Granted, I do have a 4070 Ti and 13600k, so maybe get the input of someone with a more average system.
The armor/weapon/environment systems are also pretty cool, and the loot is unique and interesting, but I haven't gotten that far into the game, so I can't say if it keeps up the pace.
Anyway, to cut this rant short, Starfield is fun, gorgeous, and a little flawed, but it's a game that's absolutely worth playing. Maybe not $100 "early access" worth playing, but I wouldn't feel ripped off if I paid $70.
I get 120fps in Elden Ring at medium, 2070, 64gb ram, i9-12900k.
Just got done with Armored Core, rock solid 144fps at medium all the way through, never a blip.
This runs at 30fps on lowest settings. It runs like absolute crap. It's incredibly jarring to go from games that are gorgeous and well made with high performance to this thing running like something 20 years ago. Absolutely zero optimisation.
It will get a seriously negative response from the average pc user when user reviews start hitting due to this performance.