'After Midnight' - an underseen '80s horror anthology

I first discovered After Midnight (1989) during my freshman year of college. There at I Luv Video was this VHS tape that gave me nostalgia for a movie I actually hadn’t seen yet. The woman on the cover, a character played by Jillian McWhirter, was quite literally trapped in time, and the tagline beneath her fiery fate read: “Anything Can Happen in the Dark.” As it turned out, my little case of memory distortion was rather fitting; this movie starts off with someone having a vague recollection, albeit of a terrible event.

Growing up I had passed by After Midnight many times at my local video shop, but it wasn’t until some years later that I gave it a watch. And after witnessing the nightmarish fate of those college students enrolled in The Psychology of Fear, I was hooked. Jim and Ken Wheat’s movie — their horror debut as directors and producers after penning Silent Scream, A Nightmare on Elm Street 4: The Dream Master, and The Fly II — has since become a favorite. You could even say my enthusiasm for anthologies today was influenced by After Midnight.

In hindsight, the VHS synopsis for After Midnight didn’t exactly advertise itself as an anthology; the only indication was the bit of “sharing stories” on the tape’s back cover. Nevertheless, I was pleasantly surprised to find another movie like Creepshow, Tales from the Darkside: The Movie, and Tales from the Hood. And it is only after the somewhat involved setup does this movie reveal itself to be an anthology. The Wheat Brothers were inspired by 1945’s Dead of Night, another horror portmanteau where the substories happen later than sooner, and the storytellers aren’t your usual Creep or Crypt Keeper types. Much like another anthology I enjoy, Campfire Tales, the narrators here are normal people. Some less so than others, but that fact is revealed later on.

...

After Midnight isn’t held in the same regard as other anthologies, and it’s not particularly scary, but this underseen movie is rich in charm and atmosphere. From my view, it showed up at the right time of my life and opened the door to even more segmented horror. And for that I’m willing to look past its lack of scares and appreciate its many other redeeming traits