Skip Navigation

is it wrong/selfish to cut contact with my trump-supporting father?

my dad specifically has really been feeding into hypermasculine, gun-loving, "true American" MAGA nonsense. I am gay and while he has no issue with me or my partner he continues to align himself with people who do not believe in my right to exist. He didn't believe Elon did a nazi salute. He said I was listening to the liberal propaganda. Now that trump has pulled out all the stops and continues to implement project 2025, I question whether I can still be in contact with him. Even if he is not (outwardly) rooting on everything, him not condemning what is happening to me seems like he is doubling down on his beliefs.

I am drained mentally and honestly think that he will continue supporting the destruction of this country and the rights of millions all because he idealizes their "alignment" with masculinity, guns, the military, traditions, etc.

How do I approach the topic with him and tell him it's either me or these beliefs/trump? Is that selfish of me? I know some people say that this will only further the divide but honestly I feel like things now are irreperable and I should not be involved with people who turn a blind eye to fascism.

80 comments
  • Something I'm seeing a lot is the statement "I'm not distancing myself because of political differences, I'm distancing myself because of moral differences"

    Anyone who is happy at the expense of others losing rights, is not different from you politically, they're different from humanity, as far as basic ethics.

    You're not selfish. You're strong. Stronger than me and I'm proud of you for trying to fight to help your dad, but please don't do it at your own expensive. I'm pan and non-monagamous but buried further in the closet than a cable that "definitely will be useful in the future" because my family would turn on me in a heartbeat.

  • It sounds like your life will be immeasurably improved by cutting him off. But it's such an intense, personal decision that I'm not sure any internet stranger could honestly say one way or the other.

  • Lol, these comments saying it's selfish.

    Selfish would be pushing that trump hate in your sons face.

    Just like cheerleading the federal job massacre when both of your kids are feds should get you ghosted.

    I would only spend any amount of time around him that you feel you want to, as someone who feels that way, you owe them none of your energy.

    You don't get to always be in someones life. That's not a constant. If you act like an asshole, that person may simply decide for their mental health to get rid of you completely. And that's on you.

    When people make mistakes, they apologize. But when someone is just telling you who they are, listen.

  • Speaking as someone who did similar:

    You will never be able to make him understand why you're cutting off contact. You may not see that now. Spork knows, I didn't for a few years. But it's true, if you try to explain he will simply try to debate or he'll push you off as immature.

    To save your own sanity, all you can do is cut ties completely.

    Other people here may offer differing advice. Some of them haven't been through this situation, so they can't know the torment you're going through.

    I can only speak from my experience.

    Cutting them off was the best thing I did for my mental health. Cutting them off was not easy. I still think of them sometimes, of what might have been. But I'm comfortable with my decision, I'm confident I made the right one. Through plenty of evidence-based psychology, I now understand the reasons.

    Getting back to your first question: sometimes, it's good to be selfish for the right reasons. Maintaining your own health and well-being? That's the right reason.

    Your father's desire to hurt people is far more selfish than making him discuss something. But if you make him discuss it, he will only act threatened and refuse to see your point of view.

    You will only begin to heal once you cut him out of your life. I don't say that lightly.

    Again, if someone hasn't lived through a situation like this (and hasn't had to make the same hard decisions), they can't understand. So don't be afraid of the naysayers.

  • No, it's not selfish, although I'm sure that's what he would want you to think. You should do what is best for you.

  • There is never any change without pain. You are in the right.

    You want him to realize he's in the wrong? It takes pain, like the pain of "Why don't my kids visit anymore?"

    If this is cruel, remember they've been doing this to you first.

  • My best friend at work is a dyed-in-the-wool conservative. He will never not be - and I rush to profess that he is not an asshole...he just thinks conservitave/republican is the side he needs to support probably because that's what daddy did, dunno. We see eye-eye on most other things.

    We do not agree on anything political except that everyone is way too heated up over everything. We are still friends, regardless.

    My point in responding is that his gay daughter disconnected from him after Trump v.1 - would not take a call or interact in any way. This is painful for my friend and he has been confused by it but does not realize why his daughter won't engage. I think she is offended that his political choice doesn't allow for her right to exist and, frankly I agree with her.

    I think my friend has lost his daughter forever because he is a stubborn man. I hope your dad can open his heart to accept you.

    • Have you ever explained things to him about his daughters viewpoints? Just tell him "Ya know, (his name), I've been thinking. People with (his hair color) shouldn't have the right to exist. People with (his hair color) are just no good, rotten nasty people! They don't have the right to live on MY planet, breathing MY air! Right? Don't you agree?"

      And make it as absurd as actual racism/homophobia is. Make it clear that you hate him for things he was born with, and he now has to pay for being a dirty (color) hair'd person! Don't be shy. Be as hateful as you've seen people like that be.

      Then ask him how he feels about you. Get him yelling at you. Get him insulting you. Ruffle his feathers. Smile at every insult he hurls.

      And then tell him "What I have just shown to you is a mirror. I have acted as you have acted to your daughter. These are the messages she hears you saying to her. It was hard to hear wasn't it? You didn't want to hear a single further thing out of my mouth. THAT is the same experience that your daughter has when you spew those same messages at her.

      YOU are an individual. YOU have the ability to change your views. All I can do is hold up the mirror to show you what version of you you're projecting into the world. Your daughter is an individual, and she has the right to live her life any way she wants. With or without you. If you care, it's up to you to be the version of yourself that she wants in her life. Not the version you try to force into her life."

      After that, there's literally nothing more you can do. Slap him with reality, and if he continues to be shitty to his family, he can die alone.

      • Oh yeah get them angry at you, than they’ll calmly sit by and listen to reason despite never reasoning themself into their belief in the first place.

        Just be honest, tell him his choice is for a country that actively hurts his daughter. If he doesn’t hate her, why enable her suffering.

  • I wouldn't know what's "wrong" or "right" in these kind of matters.

    You should do whatever is better for your mental health.

    Are you better without having contact with your father or having contact with him?

    It's the only question here.

    You should be aware that you would not change his mind with this or make him question his beliefs. If something his beliefs would probably grow stronger after something like that.

    You also should be aware that that action would have zero impact on the far right campaign.

    So if you do this is for your own mental benefit, nothing else. Don't let any kind of pressure on any direction force you to do anything that's not the best for your mental health.

    I would also consider just lowering the amount of contact and see how it goes instead of completely cut ties (an action that would have life lasting consequences)

    To be true, for what I read, if I was in your situation I wouldn't cut ties. You said that he supports you, and for me that's the important thing in a father. I personally have no issues having personal relationships with people with vastly different political ideologies. My mental health does not suffer from that. But every person is different, so you do what's best for you.

  • I don't think it's selfish. At all.

    If you let him know you'll be there for him whenever he decides to leave the cult, you're pretty much being generous. You don't owe him forgiveness, but offering it up front might also make it easier for him to one day get out. And it might make it easier on you as well.

  • you can't demand people to change, it has to come from within. you can only talk to them and try to change their point of view. that certainly may not work in this case. your issue is not about if your father can live without you, but if you can live without him. if the answer is yes, then spending less time with him may be better for your mental health. also, you don't need to cut ties immediately completely. you can do that gradually to see if it is the right decision for you.

  • Not selfish at all.

    I've cut so many people from my life. I have a rule. If you exist in my life, and all you do is make me angry, there better be a REASON you're making me angry. Like when I was TRYING to get my dad to accept help from the government a few years back. His roof is failing. It's only getting worse. Our city has a roof replacement program for seniors. Totally free roof. His house is rotting. When it rains outside, it rains inside.

    So yeah, I fought him for 2 years trying to get him to take the roof.

    Yeah I made him angry, but it's because I care about him. And the fight is about getting him to take care of himself.

    Unlike my sister, who will call, just to argue, and fight, with no real reason. I don't answer her calls.

    And when I've had "friends" that only care about you when they need something, fuck off. I'm a generous person, who people think they can take advantage of. And I guess they can to a certain extent. I don't mind helping those in need. But there comes a point when you realize "I only see this guy every few months, and only when he has some sob story, and needs something".

    THATS when I stop talking to friends. OR when I realize that I'm ALWAYS the one who has to innitiate contact. Like if I just stayed silent, the friendship would just be over. Ok then. Guess you never think about me if I'm not already in your presense. I don't need those people in my life.

  • My brother didn't vote and in person around family, he is not a Trump supporter but he is conservative. Publicly via social media, he's never once said a bad thing about Trump and has never hesitated to strawman shit on Dems. During the run up to the election, he made some comments about Kamala after the first debate, and it was all just horseshit takes. I typed a dozen messages and deleted them because what I was going to send would have been one of those things you don't come back from. Instead I've completely cut him out of my life and I'm on active avoidance. The only saving grace for him, is that I know he didn't vote for Trump, which means almost nothing, but he didn't actually do the worst thing. Because of that, in 4 years, I'm going to assess the damage of this Presidency and make a choice on if I will ever even consider seeing him again or if he's dead to me. I will never forgive him and we will never have a relationship, but there's a chance that we might both be able to go to familial gatherings, like funerals in the future.

    For me, this isn't a very difficult decision. We've never really been super close since he's quite a bit older, but we were good. I'm fully prepared to miss significant events to avoid him. I'm not sure what your relationship with your father is like, but one thing you have to consider is how it's going to affect anything else family related, like family reunions, funerals, weddings, holidays, etc. Make sure that you think of all of the effects this may have before jumping the gun and doing something you can't undo. You can certainly try and salvage the relationship and have a serious heart to heart where you lay it all out, and if that's not enough, then I suppose that the decision is easier. Alternatively, if you're ready to be done, you have the option of sending him something with a reason, telling him what's up and bye, or ghosting him. If you ghost him, that will make any chances of rebuilding a future relationship a lot harder.

    Best of luck.

  • Haven’t spoken to my brother in years because of that, and we’re not even Americans or living in America.

    I’ve cut off everyone who ever expressed a positive opinion of him.

  • It's about you, you're not doing it to make a point. You're doing it to protect your mental health. Maybe you can approach it from that angle with your father. And if he carries on the way he did then I guess he got a fair warning.

  • Just cos u don't agree with someone for some of their ideas that's no reason to cut them off. Tell him u don't agree explain why and tell him u don't want to discuss it with him and if he forces u to u will leave.

    U can fundamentally disagree with someone and still have a respectful relationship.

    Think about it from his perspective u are associating/supporting people he believe are just as bad as u believe elon/trump is. It sounds like he is still respectful of you for who you are.

    • "Yeah, sure my friend here is a nazi sympathiser, but he respects me"

      It's important to be tolerant and to respect other people even if we disagree on things. But there are limits to that.

80 comments