AITAH for judging my boyfriend for commentating during movies?

This is an automated archive.

The original was posted on /r/amitheasshole by /u/StructureOne7655 on 2023-07-27 15:42:21+00:00.

My(29F) boyfriend(39M) has this habit of commentating during movies at home and now out in public. He did it again today when watching a video on his phone. The last time it was during the movie Oppenheimer. When the countdown for detonating was going on he started counting down out loud with the guy in the movie. I elbowed him so he’d shut up. In my opinion it’s annoying and distracting to others around you. The time before that was at The Sound of Freedom. He would say stuff like “that’s fucked up” etc. Today when watching the video on his phone he says out loud while laughing, “Oh wow this guy just ran into the wall!”. I get he can be excited or what not but I just find it obnoxious. I brought it up to him and he asked “Why does it matter?” . He had an attitude of not caring what people think which is healthy to a degree but am I wrong for thinking it a bit strange to commentate?