Poland's President Calls on NATO Allies to Raise Spending on Defense to 3% of GDP
Poland's President Calls on NATO Allies to Raise Spending on Defense to 3% of GDP
President Andrzej Duda made his call in remarks directed at home and abroad. His appeal came on the eve of a visit to the White House, where U.S. President Joe Biden will receive both Duda and Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk.
I think it would be more transparent to talk about military spending as a percentage of national income. Using GDP seems like a good way to make the cost to tax payers seem smaller.
It is much fairer to use GDP.
If a nation chooses to have lots of social programs the government would need to have a higher income. This would result in higher NATO spending target. A nation that doesn't spend on social programmes would likely have a smaller government income and a reduced NATO commitment.
Additionally how the nations government works may have an effect. If a nation has lots of smaller local authorities that raise their own money and spend it themselves (like US states) then the federal/sovereign government would have a smaller income. An income that doesn't really match the nations governments spending.
GDP solves this and makes it agnostic to government structure and policies. The stronger your economy the bigger the commitment you make. Countries with less GDP per person tend to have lower labour costs. So manufacturing and military wages scale well relative to the countries population.
Maybe we should hit the 2% goal first...?
Most are, or are very close like Frances 1.9%. IIRC almost everyone is at 1.7 or above.
Sure, better be at 2 but well...
Just send 1% of GDP to Ukraine and spend 2% for the rest of the time. Sorry, but 3% is more then NATO spending during the Cold War and that was against a much stronger enemy then Russia. 3% only makes sense if we want to fight China.
What was it Trump wanted NATO nations the spending to be again back then? I think it was 2℅ or something.
Frankly, if Trump gets in again, all of Europe could raise their defense budgets to 10% or more of their GDP and Trump would still try to leave NATO, simply because he wants his Putin-sempai to notice him.
He also wanted Mexico to pay for a wall, framed Putin and other dictators as geniuses and friends, and aimed to make America great again™ despite pushing it to isolationism and irrelevancy.
Let's not take a single sensible thing he said as some kind of huge win, especially when this has been the stance of US presidents before him as well. The only difference is that now war is close enough to EU that western countries started to wake up about the need to defend themselves.
Trump: make america great again, again.
How about no. Nato is already by far the strongest military force, and Russia is the weakest it's ever been.
Probably because the 3%+ of the (very big) American economy might go away if trump gut gets elected.