I stuck mostly to smaller subreddits that had tighter communities full of regulars. The kinds of places that don’t make it to the frontpage, and don’t have posts slathered with dozens of awards.
In smaller communities, getting an award was rarer but it actually felt good because you knew it wasn’t from a bot or whatever that was trying to pump up visibility for cynical reasons.
I really liked the smaller subreddits too, but they've all been going down hill for the last several years. You can't say shit on reddit without a good chance of being banned from either that subreddit, or reddit in general. So, fuck it.
I don't know, to me getting gold or platinum always made me happy, even more recently (up until I quit Reddit). It said someone liked what you said enough to make an effort to show you and give you a little present. At least, that's how I interpreted it.
I'm done with Reddit, I think Reddit has gone to shit, but that particular aspect made me smile because someone did something nice for me.