Dungeons Keeper 2, Heroes of Might and Magic III, medieval 2 Total war and Sid Meiet's Pirates!
I love them, but they're too old and I'm sure there's a modern version somewhere that's better. Also you won't get why theyre fantastic unless you were there when they came out. All games that scratch an itch no other game does.
I really enjoyed DK2 and Sid Meier's Pirates, but I think last time I tried to get either to run on my system they just wouldn't run. I'd love to give 'em a go again.
Don't tell anyone, but someone I know loved Dungeon Keeper to such an extent they walked out of the local mall with a copy of Dungeon Keeper 2 under their shirt.
Crazy I know. Keep in mind, this may have occurred during the annual "Crazy Dayz" event where they just put bins of crap out at 75% off. Crazy I tells ya.