Bigoted community on your instance
Bigoted community on your instance
https://lemmy.world/c/christians
Rule 8 of this community is in clear breach of the first goal from the lemmy/mastodon.world code of conduct
You're viewing a single thread.
Permanently Deleted
Can you expand on that please? It's a pretty open and shut case.
The current guidelines are in clear contravention of the guidelines of your instance.
Locking the thread with no detail is not an appropriate response to this.
Permanently Deleted
Thanks for the update!
Permanently Deleted
This is a lemmy support community and the discussions should be kept to that
The sidebar of lemmy.world points to this community as the one to raise issues relating to lemmy.world
I think what they mean is the mods of this community aren't expecting to have to moderate ideological discussions over bigotry, just to handle support requests. Which, well, I contributed to myself, but I get it.
Can I have breakfast too or nah lol
Thank you for the quick response to this, y'all haven't let me down with a decision yet
I didn't want to remove it out of a kneejerk reaction. They had this in their sidebar:
-
Rule #6: Banned subjects include pro-Nazi and/or pro-racist sentiments; support for conspiracy theories such as Q-Anon, International Jewish Conspiracy, Holocaust denialism, etc.; “is X the mark of the Beast?” drivel; anything calling for direct/indirect violence against any individual or group, including LGBTQ+ individuals or groups; pornography of any kind; gore; spam; asking for money; pro-Mormon and/or pro-Jehovah’s Witness posts.
-
And then there was rule 8 🙄
It's a difficult line to toe, why not work with them to let them have a community rather than directly ban them?
Similarly if they do move, do you defedeate?
I'm pro LGBTQ+ but not talking about something isn't the same as actively being against something.
If this is the direction of lemmy world, I'm fine with that, but it would be good to set clear boundaries that a lot of religions have no home on lemmy world so they don't waste time building a community here then get it nuked from orbit.
I think our views on LGBQT are clearly laid out on https://mastodon.world/about
There is a difference between hosting those communities here and federating with instances who have them.
Unless it turns out to be problematic we won't defederate.
Makes sense, thank you for your hard work and clarity!
Lol, let me shoot an arrow to my own knee real quick
I think you made a rushed decision, you are creating a dangerous precedent and you will be bombarded by people being outraged by minor things requesting you to ban communities for no good reason. In this case, if there was a violation it could be resolved with discussion instead of an outright ban.
Read my edit. They can send an appeal to info@mastodon.world
The community was not even active, so there is no one maybe to send an appeal. If you look at the upvote, and downvote ratio of this post, you can see that there is no unanimous opinion on this case, and the decision should be taken more carefully on this one. If you don't want to push your other users out of the instance.
They have a rule in the sidebar that clearly goes against the instance rules. They can appeal and if they don't have anyone to do that there is another problem because that goes against the moderation rules on this instance.
You could delete the rule and then put a post in the community asking for someone to step up to moderate.
I'm glad to see rules being enforced in the face of bigotry instead of the constant leniency to which bigots have become accustomed and to which they regard themselves as entitled.
And then there would be people complaining that we as admins go around changing community rules behind moderator's backs. You can't please everyone.
We leave the door open for the moderators of that community to sort things out.
Maybe to clarify when we delete a community, all posts are still there. They are just "invisible" so nothing is lost.
-
Thank you for your work
Merci a toi 😊