Alleged Switch modder takes on Nintendo’s legal might without a lawyer
Alleged Switch modder takes on Nintendo’s legal might without a lawyer
Pro se legal filing denies all of Nintendo’s accusations, offers some novel defenses.
dude just presented his cheeks to bareback for nintendo
That is definitely not good. A saying among the legal community is that a lawyer that represents himself has a fool for a lawyer. If he is going to stand up to Nintendo, he should at least be crowdfunding for a professional legal defense.
Dude is fucked, but I'm rooting for him all the same.
Not only was he selling modchips, he was selling modded consoles. He's fucked.
I wish you strength and might warrior.
The title, worded like that, sounds like some brave man waving a sword at a mighty dragon...
Upon reading the article the situation is more like a bafoon waving a toothpick at an elder god
Rather Dashing gonna yeet his sword at Trogdor
Who is gonna end up fucking it up so bad Nintendo gets the precedent they need to shut down all emulation forever.
Yea, so many other occurrences I wish had gone to court, this one not only doesn't stand a chance, but will set bad precedence.
Many such lawsuits have ended in settlements outside of courts, so I'm guessing many legal claims have not been validated or invalidated in court yet. This can be good or bad of course. But now, if this guy goes to court, I'm actually concerned because it may give an unchallenged path to Nintendo's legal arguments and assuming the court decides he's guilty, there will be precedent of these legal claims having been vetted in court. Would that not be worse for anyone in the future who would want to challenge Nintendo's legal claims?
Rule #1 about going to court against a large company with good lawyers: don't represent yourself, since there's no way you'll win, and the judgment will likely require you to cover at least some of Nintendo's legal fees.
Rule #1 about going to court
against a large company with good lawyers: don’t represent yourself,since there’s no way you’ll win, and the judgment will likely require you to cover at least some of Nintendo’s legal fees."The man who represents himself in court has a fool for a lawyer and an idiot for a client."
This is only true if you prioritize your own well being.
If you prioritize authentic truth you must go in alone and accept that the system will swallow you. No one knows your honest perspectives better than you, a lawyer will compromise your morality in order to protect you because for them this is just a means to an income, they don’t share your passion for justice.
Basically become a token/martyr.
What you gain is observable truth that the system is broken and makes you its victim trough bureaucratic oppression, giving you an ethical reason to rebel further against it.
I very much DO NOT recommend this but in another way i feel like the ethics of the system are not frequently enough challenge by actual good.
Objection! Hearsay!
True, but it's especially true when they're up against Nintendo.
The legal system is an irredeemable joke.
It is and it isn't. The judicial process is a very complex system. There is hundreds of years of case precedent to consider. There is nuance to every situation. Judges and juries are meant to be impartial, and its the lawyers that need to argue convincingly that their appraisal of the law is more valuable than the opponent lawyer's appraisal of the law. It is literally the most sophisticated method of determining the truth in a matter of legal wrongdoing. Copyright law is a fairly clear cut area of law, and this guy was bold faced selling Nintendo hardware that he modded.
Now, criminal law on the other hand. That's a complete joke.
Fly you fool
At that time, Daly agreed "both verbally and in signed writing" to refrain from these infringing sales, according to Nintendo. It was only after months of Daly continuing those sales and largely ignoring further contact from Nintendo that the company says it was forced to file its June lawsuit in a Seattle federal court.
if that's the case, I can't see it going well for him...
Heck, he'd probably have been fine if he just stopped selling cards with roms preinstalled, but kept the normal modding stuff up
He was selling chips preloaded with pirated games. No wonder he's representing himself: no one bothered to defend him.
Highlight from the comments
It sounds like His defense might be ChatGPT, Throwing everything at the wall.
I fear his previous counsel was ChatGPT, and it noped out.
Sovereign citizen defense incoming.
You either die a hero, or you live long enough to become Nintendo.
Fuck Nintendo. Come on, someone grab* this pro bono... There has to be some bored, rich af partner out there who wants to tilt at windmills.
Client is too crazy, and it’s Nintendo. Lawyers won’t touch this.
Yeah this doesn’t exactly sound like a Mr. Smith goes to Washington type…
Nah this isn't usual Nintendo bullshit, this guy was installing pirated games as part of his mods - he's brought this on himself.
Nah man, as much as I might dislike Nintendos business practices, this dude in particular only has himself to blame. Dude literally sold pirated games, signed an agreement with Nintendo to stop, then didn’t. Not surprised no one would want that case.
Nobody's going to go against Nintendo pro-bono lol
At best you may be able to find a lawyer that'll work on a contingency basis, but they tend to only take cases that they're fairly confident they'll win (since they don't make any money if they lose)
Unfortunately the number of people who need a lawyer's help is far greater than the number of helpful lawyers.
I really think The Simpsons missed the mark with their "8 lawyers per person" joke.
Maybe he has something up his sleeve we don't know about
Like maybe he's going to prove that Nintendo was emulating his work all along? (/s)
Maybe he doesn't want to spend 50k for a case he's losing anyway.
Not legal advice, but I believe denying all facts even the ones that are obviously true is setting himself up to pay costs for proving those facts, even if he was to win overall.
Nintendo are over litigious and have a reputation for weaponising copyright laws to shut down legitimate competition - but I suspect this might not be a good test case for challenging this.
Let the man cook!
This isn't a smart play, but it forced Nintendo to spend more of their legal team's time on him, rather than the emulation community, so I support his suicide mission.
Brave, but foolhardy.
He will literally die
You know what they say about someone who represents themselves in court?
They have an idiot for a client.
Rest in piece you brave soul.
His balls are Jupiter and Neptune
His brain is a lepton.
bold_move.gif
Also his last move
His last will be garnished wages from his mcjob
The fate of us all \ lies deep in the dark \ when time stands still at the Iron Hill
good luck to him even though it seems futile. nintendo really needs to get fucked then pound sand after, but this doesn't seem like the one. Hopefully it doesn't just end up benefitting Nintendo more.
Hope he has a spot in the wilderness to hide out.