What's with all the "removed?"
I frequently see removed in a lot of posts and comments. I'm guessing there's some kind of filter at work? I checked my Voyager settings and I don't see that I've blocked any words, is this happening server side?
From context, it looks like the censored words are pretty common, and not especially potent, curse words. Is this really necessary?
It’s server-side. The b-word (sexist slur against women), r-word (intellectual disability) tend to be the most common caught ones (I’d say 95%) though the f-word against queer people and other more and less obvious racial ones are included as well.
It doesn’t impact swears that aren’t denigrating such as fuck, shit, ass, damn, etc.
If it’s essential you see those words you’d need to create a new account on another instance like lemm.ee or something.
I can see removing the r-word. I can kinda see removing the f-word, but it is being reclaimed by some (my ex, for example.) the b-word seems overkill. it's commonly reclaimed, used in many different contexts, and part of common non-slur phrases. examples:
yes, it can be used as a sexist slur, but "queer" and "gay" can too. language is nuanced, regexes are not.
It's as commonly abused as it is "reclaimed", in a male-dominated space like this it's more abused than reclaimed. One could make the same arguments for the n-word and black people reclaiming it, thing is online there's no way to know who is black, who is a woman, and who is a white man who claims to be a black woman online so he can use words like that and get away with it.
Online moderators are not suited to identifying and organizing a system of n-word and b-word passes to people through verification so we have to assume many, many uses would be in bad faith by people not part of those groups in a potentially hurtful or offensive way.
I want to note I didn't implement this and have no power over it but I do find it kind of shocking since opening an account here how often people use the b-word online casually and I do not think most of them are women.
Queer and gay I'd say have been completely reclaimed. The last time you saw "gaaay" as an insult in popular culture was probably the 2000s decade in young adult media. Whereas to this year you see new media of some angry man screaming "you b-word" hatefully at a woman being made all the time. Men just know it's something you call a woman or girl when you're angry at her, men just know it's a sexist slur, a softer one that the w-word for promiscuous but one just the same used in anger to attack women. When that stops happening, when it's not in media when a generation of young men think it's no longer acceptable even in anger to do that perhaps there might be a point to what you say.
I admit it can make following things confusing at times. I kind of wish it censored it in the form of B
<removed>
or something to indicate which one it was.I also agree regexes are not nuanced, I've seen false positives based on some pretty obscure ones. But it's policy set by the admins of this instance so the choice is basically accept it or move to another instance like lemm.ee.
Yes, it’s a server-side regex-based slur filter.
Is this really necessary?
The developers wouldn’t have created it and the admins wouldn’t have enabled it if they didn’t think so.
I wonder if you might make an exception for the b-word, per the case I've made here? https://lemmy.ml/comment/17736838
I honestly haven't heard the b-word used much as an intentionally sexist slur outside of like, 4chan. I (female) say it to my female friends pretty casually. even when I hear it used as a curse word (usually as -ing), it doesn't come across as a slur. for example, I hear it applied to men with roughly equal frequency as women. it's also pretty reclaimed ("she's a badass b-word.")
maybe could try taking it out, and maybe put it back if people are using it in a sexist way? (though hopefully sexists are disciplined rather than just having a single word in a sexist diatribe censored.)
I believe there is an automod that removes an archaic, but still occasionally properly used, term for a female dog and a couple other terms. Seems to be mostly a set of words whose common usage has its roots in bigotry.
If an account gets banned all of their comments get removed automatically. They will all say "removed by mod"
That is not OP is talking about, and it’s not true. Posts & comments only get removed if the ban is done with “Remove Content,” AKA remove_data, which in practice is seldom chosen. https://lemmy.readme.io/reference/post_user-ban