Other than Fireball, What's the best spell for cooking?
Other than Fireball, What's the best spell for cooking?
Remember to always check creative uses of spells with your DM.
You can only make one object. I could understand if it was a big pot of soup, but I don't see how this counts as one object.
Here's how I'd use Fabricate to cook:
- Fabricate plate mail.
- Sell the plate mail.
- Use the money to hire a chef.
This presents several problems.
-
What is "one object"? A proper suit of platemail is like 30 objects, the helm is a different object to the breastplate, and that is a different object to the left sabaton. Such a ruling could cause a lot of table arguments.
-
Why is "a banquet" different to "a suit of platemail" in this regard? They're both comprised of several smaller components that could individually be described as objects?
-
The spell doesn't explicitly say "you can only make one object" it repeatedly, and irresponsibly careens wildly from using singular examples, and using plurals. The first line of the spell text is "You convert raw materials into products of the same material." (plural) It then gives examples of "a bridge, a rope, clothes" (singular, singular, plural).
I don't see a sage advice on this issue specifically but Crawford has answered "can you make a full set of artisans tools with a casting of fabricate" with yes - and most sets of tools aren't "one object" either...
Remember to check creative uses of your spells with your DM. Your DM is at risk and your DM can go down as well as up, and you may not get back all the DM that you put in.
-
Your argument is that a banquet is multiple items and your solution is making plate mail?
It really shouldn't be, but the game treats it as one. For example, the Cleric Forge's Channel Divinity blessing.
You conduct an hour-long ritual that crafts a nonmagical item that must include some metal: a simple or martial weapon, a suit of armor, ten pieces of ammunition, a set of tools, or another metal object.
This is more specific than the general rule
For the purpose of these rules, an object is a discrete, inanimate item like a window, door, sword, book, table, chair, or stone, not a building or a vehicle that is composed of many other objects.
So in the case of armor, it counts as one object even though it's not a discrete item. But unless there's something calling a feast one object, it follows these rules.
If you allow a feast, what doesn't count as "one object"?
The object is dinner
I do love when someone jumps in to "well actually" all over people who are just having fun - and their assertions are just wrong.
Yeah and using it to cook dinner is much less broken than using it to generate 1500 GP from the 5e commerce that is not a simulation of any actual economy.
If I had a player use it for a narrative meal, I'd absolutely allow it, and if they were using it to just generate gold, I'd make them jump through hoops to find a buyer.
Need to light the campfire? Prestidigitation! Also works to extinguish it.
Dropped a spoon on the ground? Prestidigitation! It's clean again!
Lost the spoon? Prestidigitation! You have a new one for twelve seconds, long enough for a quick stir.
Forgot a spice and the flavor is off? Prestidigitation! Your meal now tastes exactly how you want it to.
Need to call the party to eat? Prestidigitation! You create a flare, the sound of a chime, or just spread the smell of cooked food around.
Left the food out too long and now it's cold? Prestidigitation! It's the perfect temperature again. Also works for chilling drinks (your booze hounds will thank you).
Post-meal cleanup? Done in under a minute no matter how messy the barbarian eats, thanks once again to prestidigitation.
Barbarian: PUNCH. If you hit the chicken enough times, eventually you'll impart enough energy to cook it.
If you ever wondered how many time you'd actually need to
Punch cow instead. It's safe to eat raw.
Ah man, this just made me remember how much I miss the daily Konsi comics.
I wish I could draw faster, but this process takes a lot of steps, and I substitute my lack of raw talent with time spent.
That's a brilliant use for Fabricate! I'd totally allow it.
Reminder that WotC tried to retroactively revoke the OGL
You could always try curing your meat
That's not what I meant!
Animate dead + purify food and drink. Pull off a spare rib whenever and wherever you need it.
Mirage Arcane. They may be eating twigs and leaf mulch, but they will enjoy it.
You make terrain in an area up to 1 mile square look, sound, smell, and even feel like some other sort of terrain.
No mention of taste. You'd better make it smell really good. Or just use Prestidigitation.
You can make the argument taste is just extreme smell.
This adds a whole new dimension to "chewing the furniture"
Pathfinder has a spell called Allfood, makes literally anything into "food" (well, it's tasteless mush, but it is edible). Creative uses include: chewing through doors, literally eating important MacGuffins, and disarming opponents via CHOMP.
Hooray another chapter!
...aaaand now I'm hungry.
I'd allow it.
I guess Heroes feast does not really count as cooking so...:
- You could use wish and wish for the meal to be cooked perfectly
- Mage hand is very helpful when you want to lift a hot pot or pan.
- Since objects made by creation are real for the duration of the spell, you could create some food, it eat and even give your stomach time to... salvage the valuable parts before the spell ends
The perfect diet food, maybe?
I think that, generally speaking, food that's magically generated for a temporary period of time counts as "real" if you eat it - you get the nutrition from it. (c.f. Magnificent Mansion) - which raises interesting questions about the metaphysics of DnD.
Depends on the amount work put into the magic systems lore from the DMs side. (I once wrote the ,,Theorie of magical trinity: Command, energy and will" and there's a lot of other work out in the internet as well)
Immediately thought of hero's feast, but fabricate works too
Animate Dead
Wall of fire.