Basically what I did with Cyberpunk and FO4. Had zero urge to try Starfield, noticed it basically dropped off the map for most people a few weeks after release.
This was my biggest complaint tbh. My main issues are all writing and narrative stuff. I enjoy the big open clockwork worlds and prefer them over more focused and polished stuff. Those usually feel more on rails and lifeless to me.
Cyberpunk's main quest line felt like it should have been the first act, I stopped thinking about it as soon as I finished. I finished FO4 in like a week and then never touched it again. I did try and set up a modded playthrough with all the DLC because I'd heard Far Harbour was solid, but I kept getting CTDs as soon as I left the vault and couldn't be fucked to figure out what was causing it.