There needs to be a global login button for Mastodon/Lemmy

Stop thinking Reddit and start thinking email. You don’t log in to Hotmail with your gmail address to read mail sent to you from hotmail.

But I would use my Gmail to login into other services like Evernote or Spotify as an example.
Permanently Deleted
- And you can write an app that will lie about the address of someone posting on ActivityPub. What's your point?
  
  Mine is that you log in to your e-mail provider to access the content you are interested in. You don't go logging in to other e-mail providers because that is where the people creating the content are.

None of the Fediverse has this nor is it practical as not all servers will be running the same software, many modify theirs with custom things. If you want an application to act as a container, try Ferdium. https://github.com/ferdium/ferdium-app

I had no clue about this! This looks actually decent, will try this later!

Why? You only need a login to your home instance. Federating the content is done by your instance. So why the need for a "global login button"?

The pain point is if someone sends you a link to a post on a different instance you kind of have to jump through a hoop to interact with it
- There are plugins to fix that. However, I dislike that approach, but it's all we have at the moment and it works.
I got into a link posted somewhere in a post that took me to wikipedia's mastodon but I'm registered on mastodon.world. And this has not been a single instance, happened plenty of times with other lemmy instances.
- There are browser extensions that solve this for Mastodon instances. I'm sure the Lemmy and Kbin equivalents will arrive in due course.

This was the great promise of the fediverse -- that you would own your profile, and that you would have one profile across the entire fediverse, and that you could migrate that profile from instance to instance if you had disagreements with the admins of your instance -- but it seems to have fallen by the wayside with real implementations, which is disappointing.

Real baffled with the met resistance, this is a huge QoL that would provide ease of access for new users.
This was the great promise of the fediverse

Promised by who, when? Seriously - I don’t remember it being a part of the proposition
- https://w3c.github.io/did-core/
If you want one profile across the entire fediverse, then host your own instance? Or link your accounts to one central website you own or to one profile you own, e.g. Mastodon or Matrix.
- I don't think "you can host your own instance" is a very realistic solution for the vast majority of social media users. "Just learn to be a sysadmin so you can post memes" is pretty user-hostile.

There's a plugin that redirects all instances you're browsing to re-open on your home instance. Perhaps that's something you're looking for?

This a good workaround, but it's a turnoff for newcomers without this natively.

Nope, it really doesn't need that, just use any of the web clients if you need that.

But lemmy, nor Mastodon, nor Pixelfed, nor kbin need that.

No thanks. We're an instance focused on the queer and gender diverse community. Not a convenient generic login proxy for the entire Fediverse.

No we aren't. We are an instance focused on autonomy and anti-censorship.

(Yes this is somewhat sarcastic, as I'm trying to point out that you are posting on a federated forum. Your instance focused is irrelevant to everyone but your own users)
- Your instance focused is irrelevant to everyone but your own users
  
  Well yes, that's rather the point. I run this instance for my community. I have no interest in turning my instance in to a generic login proxy for "free speech"
A global login wouldn't break a defedaration, it would simply spit out some error such as "Your credentials are invalid, your home instance is not federated with this instance."
- Well yes, but most of the instances we federate with aren't queer or gender diverse. And the reason we pay for the costs of our instance out of our own pockets is because we are interested in fostering and developing our community of folk who are queer and gender diverse

That's literally what the web apps are.

Skill issue.

Edit: Downvote away, it's not like this suggestion warranted actual meaningful discussion. It's just somebody who fundamentally doesn't understand how the fediverse works and thankfully the comments are reflecting that.

Edit: replying in an edit because this post doesn't deserve more engagement with a new comment.

@orientalsniper: I know how the fediverse works, been promoting it since the APIception.

That's cool and all but platform promotion does not equal platform understanding. Especially since you're asking questions like this from Raddle of all places rather than looking at the info on GitHub or any of the documentation linked in instances (at the bottom of the page above the code link). I stand by my statement that OP does not understand how the fediverse works and I'm still happy the comments appropriately flamed this suggestion.

Needs better Gaming Chair.
- I think it's the lack of frame rate and no mechanical keyboard
I know how the fediverse works, been promoting it since the APIception.