Hollywood's 'Groundbreaking' AI Proposal for Actors Is a Nightmare
Hollywood's 'Groundbreaking' AI Proposal for Actors Is a Nightmare
SAG-AFTRA said that AMPTP's AI plan included scanning background actors and using their likeness "for the rest of eternity."
SAG-AFTRA said that AMPTP's AI plan included scanning background actors and using their likenesses "for the rest of eternity."
Here is an alternative Piped link(s): https://piped.video/O46WEaUuIoo
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I'm open-source, check me out at GitHub.
At least Bojack got paid
Getting some real Black Mirror vibes from this story.
I just saw the episode you're referring to - yes definitely got those vibes as well.
I'm surprised there's not much abuzz yet in the recording industry for artists voice use. That seems like it'd be much easier to do and exploit. Think there's already a lot of content using AI voice generation for parodying Obama, Trump, Biden, etc. This is going to get a lot bigger.
"You wouldn't steal an actor, would you?"
It's almost like we need an entirely new legal framework to ensure the non wealthy a standard of living while being continuously devalued over time by me technological developments. Artists already sell their souls to survive in this "market."
Amen
I love how they do this right after the Black Mirror episode comes out. Black Mirror is really doing a good job of getting us ready for the future.
The future is here and it fucking sucks.
Machines create art while people deliver packages.
FWIW, this is kinda happening right now, albeit in a sort of "innocent" garage project sort of way. There are mods for Skyrim that take the voice work created by skilled actors, and use it to generate convincing additional dialog that they never consented to nor got paid for. Laura Baily is already seeing herself being AI'd by her own fans.
And this is with homemade software. Wait until the good stuff comes out.
If Tiktok simply added a perfect Biden and Trump voice filter that one action would likely fuck up our politics more than all of the Russian interference in 2016 combined.
The difference is they almost certainly can't make money off of those. I hope that forward looking games negotiate contracts with their actors for mods using their performances to be commercial, and they get part of that revenue. It would be great for the modding scene to be able to have "voice-acted" content that fit into the game without the resources that the studio has.
I agree with the actors but this article isn't great.
Actors, writers, and multimedia artists are all having their jobs threatened because of low-return, high-yield AI and generative products that do not have the ability to replicate human work and should not be utilized in order to do so.
If AI can't replicate human work then there wouldn't be a problem. If the AI were terrible, products made with it would be as well.
The entire fear is that AI can (or will soon be able to) do a decent job at these tasks.
AI being insufficient is temporary, the question is how temporary.
You're right that it'll get better, but I agree it likely won't be the same as a human. The difference is it'll cost nothing in comparison. That's the threat. If they can get the job done 80% as well with a fraction of 1% of the cost, they're probably taking it. They don't want to use AI because it's just as good or better, but because it's a hell of a lot cheaper.
Permanently Deleted
I don't think they even need it anymore. AI can create realistic human faces. I don't understand this proposal
I'm going to go out on a limb and assume that paying someone $200 for a scan is cheaper than creating a person from nothing, and that's the only reason they want it.
Extras are part of the union (SGA-AFTRA). This is why SGA is striking (well one major reason). This is why all major statements from SGA have been that they are starting with extras but will continue on to marginalize and exploit others in the union. Because that’s what capitalism does. It is how it functions if left unchecked.
The unions know that do-nothing parasites that own the studios and other businesses want to get labor cost down to essentially nothing. And they will do everything possible to get it there including openly stating they have more money than god and will simply wait out every single writer and actor until they go bankrupt on strike.
If they sign this as an extra, then get famous five years from now...
Their likeness is already sold. And the studio they sold the likeness too can use that instead of the actor.
They may even be able to "lease" the likeness to other studios.
Maybe it’s not so much about the technical part, but more on the legal part? Sure, they can use generative tech to do this and continue to improve upon it, but they don’t have permissions yet and this proposal is just to cover their bases. Hopefully SAG can shut it down completely, as one can presume that this looks like a “door-in-the-face” technique, and the industry will keep tuning the proposal until some actors give in and have big enough checks, which could then cascade to affect the whole industry.
Thanks, makes sense
You're right, there's no reason they can't just make a fully artificial human likeness that doesn't require anyone to sign over rights. That only leaves one other rational for this, which is that they want to trick desperate actors into handing over their likeness so if they get famous in the future they can control them.
Good point. I believe this is the best explanation
It's common in Hollywood for a studio to ask for right in perpetuity for any digital asset. That is so that if they remaster a movie they have everything they need to make it without having to get lawyers and contracts involved.
The directors cut is technically a different movie than then regular one and is different from an 8k remaster in the future.
That's a very different issue to someone making an entirely new movie, with that scan as a "character" though.
Not different at all. Actors do mo-cap work all the time and the performance data is owned by the studio and can be reused on different movies without royalties. The studios are trying to extend that. I see both sides. If the actors don't take a stand it could be tragic.
Lemmino did a video about it: https://piped.video/watch?v=RQdxHi4_Pvc