Skip Navigation

If Red Dead Redemption 2 is your favorite game you are probably deeply unhappy

Never played the game (fuck westerners lol) but I notice there is a correlation between being deeply immersed in rdr2 and being miserable

36

You're viewing a single thread.

36 comments
  • No, my spouse plays it primary for the online component. He enjoys riding horses, customizing them, dressing up his player in different outfits, going on missions with other players, collecting with other players, bounties, hunting, building a trade business, doing competitive pvp, and a lot of soft gameplay and RP like drinking and dancing in moonshine shacks, getting into bar fights, playing poker in saloons, making an ongoing story for his character that involves his online friends… etc.

    It’s a perfect game for the sandbox MMO crowd. I played it for a while and enjoyed it too for a bit, but I think I need more story in my face and tactics like in BG3.

    • Is there a feasible way to fight on the side of the natives? I've considered getting into it, but not really been a huge fan of the GTA sandbox/amusement park style games in a while. Like could I persistently help grow a native controlled region on the game map or something?

      • Interesting that you ask that. My spouse plays as a native woman and even has a backstory based on real life. As far as I know, there is no native “faction” you can control or anything like that.

        To be honest, beyond your appearance there isn’t any difference between player “races” in the game code. So no NPC is ever going to care if you are black, white, native, etc. They probably did that on purpose.

      • In the single player story, you’re dragged into an Indian war. Your camp sides with the Natives against the US military out of opportunistic and spiteful reasons, and the elders don’t necessarily approve of it either. But you end up sympathizing with them anyway. It doesn’t try to be “both sides bad,” more like “selfish white men pretending to care about our cause revealed that the US government never had any intentions of being peaceful and fair, and believing they did resulted in more massacres.”

        There’s also an arc where you kill slavers and domestic collaborators in imperial not-Cuba (because Cuba also exists in the universe, but the island is based on Cuba and other banana republics). From the dialogue of the guards, it’s implied that the slave rebels are socialists. There’s also a nexus between the corporate slavery in not-Cuba and the American oil companies that employ Pinkertons.

        Like could I persistently help grow a native controlled region on the game map or something?

        No. Online is just about accumulating and consuming product. The fashion is nice.

      • Within the story of the game there are indigenous people, and you can decide whether and how to help them resist the US army. I thought it was respectful although it seemed pretty pessimistic about their predicament at that time. There's a debate between indigenous characters as to what effectively preserving their people means against an enemy like the US.

        But I'm a cracker so what do I know.

You've viewed 36 comments.