Judge denies HP's plea to throw out all-in-one printer lockdown lawsuit - AiO devices won't scan or fax without ink, and plaintiffs say IT giant illegally withheld that info from buyers

www.theregister.com Judge denies HP's request to dismiss printer lockdown suiit

AiO devices won't scan or fax without ink, and plaintiffs say IT giant illegally withheld that info from buyers

Judge denies HP's plea to throw out all-in-one printer lockdown lawsuit - AiO devices won't scan or fax without ink, and plaintiffs say IT giant illegally withheld that info from buyers::AiO devices won't scan or fax without ink, and plaintiffs say IT giant illegally withheld that info from buyers

44 comments

Am I the only one who thinks it's crazy that the only grounds they have are that HP didn't disclose that their All-In-Ones won't let you scan or fax without ink and not, you know, the fact that they do that in the first place? It should be illegal to disable critical functions of a device simply because an unrelated function is temporarily unavailable. There's no technical reason HP is doing this other than, "fuck you, buy more ink."
- Unfortunately this is the difference between illegal and unethical, and I don't gather that HP cares much about ethics. Hopefully right-to-repair laws will cover these cases in the future too.
  
  I think this is the perfect example.
  
  What they did was legal but man it’s unethical
  
  It's anti-consumer, but I guess that just falls under unethical for now
- I recently had a printer to configure (IT) that was HP, and it needed an internet connection and registration to print over USB (well, at all); guess what? Dead ethernet port. Now (even with a working USB) the printer is just landfill food waiting to reach our bloodstream in a few years time. I ~~fucking hate~~ love HP!
- Guess who the laws are actually designed to protect
- The last and only printer that I bought from HP worked well and didn’t pull any shenanigans, it was a Laserjet 5L.
  
  Since then, feedback from colleagues and what I’ve seen from reviews and tech communities put me off buying HP again. Between their cloud printing, their inkjet cartridge verification and the USB ports covered in stickers and now this…
  
  Yeah HP is a disaster.
  
  They used to make good calculators too, including a financial model so good that I bought an Android emulator.
  
  I still have a LaserJet 4000N in service (circa 1997 - same era as the 5L) and it's a workhorse that never dies. Once upon a time, HP did take pride in their products. Even then, though, their toner cartridges were abusively overpriced - they just hadn't yet figured out how to prevent 3rd party competition.
- I mean, you can sell a shitty product, that's not a crime, the crime is the false advertising or if it is a danger to people
- Imagine in the future, your car just stopped working entirely and lock you out because your heated-seats subscription expired.
- Canon did this to me years ago. Maybe 15. I haven't given one cent to Canon since, and I was a big fan at the time with their cameras and such.
  
  Fucking greedy assholes
HP are a real scumbag company.
Permanently Deleted
- This might be too cruel. But what if we made them use cheap shitty printers for the rest of their life.
  
  Permanently Deleted
- And we get to spray them with cheap 3rd party ink
  
  Permanently Deleted
I still don't get why anyone is buying inkjet printers for the past 20 years. It makes zero sense to me.
- Color laser printers are very expensive and still don't achieve the same picture quality as an inkjet printer. And I have read once that dust from laser printers might cause cancer but not sure how much there really is to that.
  
  Color lasers are about $300 dollars, do better quality, and have 10x the output per cartridge on a bad day. And they don't dry rot when left without printing for extended periods. Replace the ink on an inkjet more than twice, and a laser is already a better deal.
  
  Not just that, but it’s impossible to find a colour laser that’ll do 11x17 and duplex. I think my only option is a small office printer lease.
  
  No they're not, and the quality is better. Quit lying.
- My in-laws gave my son an HP Envy. I placed a big Apple logo next to the HP logo. I have Apple logos on my trash bins too. Basically, any trash around the house gets an Apple logo stuck to it
  
  So brave
- Why is anyone buying a printer at all?
  
  Hey, printer people out there! What do you you use your printer for? My printer is just sitting idle collecting dust. Can’t think of anything I would need to print. Everything is digital these days.
  
  In less developed countries, you'd need printed copies for a lot of stuff, especially legal documents.
  
  Speaking from experience.
  
  I have a printer for the occasional need to print documents. Mind blowing I know, but that's why I keep one around. It gathers dust most of the time, but it's super useful when the odd need arises.
  
  I for one can't read correctly anything longer than a lemmy post on a screen. I print more or less anything that I'm want to read with my brain fully present - I usually outline and comment on paper too, makes it easier to remember. Latest use case : printing out dnd character sheets to do my charac design for BG3
- My guess. Marketing.
“IT giant illegally left out that info”. Bruh. THEY LIED!
- They did, but that's not a legal term, so a judge won't use it.
The printer scene: https://youtu.be/N9wsjroVlu8
- Here is an alternative Piped link(s): https://piped.video/N9wsjroVlu8
  
  Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
  
  I'm open-source, check me out at GitHub.
- One of my favourite movies ngl
Permanently Deleted
I have no printers in my house. I refuse that entire industry. Its a scam.

You've viewed 44 comments.