Your average guy is Jason Alexander in shallow hall with a total smokeshow interested in them and they won't go out with her because her finger is weird.
We already did this discourse, women do the exact same thing just with different traits.
If the Disney's Beast didn't have broad shoulders, large hands, and big forearms than his popularity among women would drop significantly. These traits are the male equivalent of "pretty face and big boobs." You could slap them on to anything and at least someone find them attractive.