FoodPorn @lemmy.world bighatchester @lemmy.world 4 mo. ago

I made shepards pie but with steak!

51 comments

afaik shepards pie with other types of meats is called a cottage pie
- You disrespect fisherman's pie
- Australia checking in. We love our pies. Pop potato on the top? Potato pie. Chicken instead of beef? Chicken pie. Lamb pie. Curry pie. Etc.
  
  We also have shepherds pie but frankly that’s just a shitty potato pie without the pastry.
  
  (Tongue in cheek, having some fun at the expense of the Poms getting all hot under the collar that someone mislabelled a cottage pie. Almost as bad as the yanks.)
- Yeah but most people just call it shepards pie either way.
  
  "most people" is likely geographically influenced. I'm guessing you're in the US.
  
  In the UK and Ireland, where the dish originated, "most people" would tell you it's a Shepherd's pie because shepherds herd she(e)p, not cows.
  
  Source: American that moved to the UK
  
  No they don't.
  
  Shepard, sheep herd, sheep.
  
  If I ordered shepherd's pie and it came with any meat other than mutton I'd be unhappy because it's not shepherd's pie. Maybe this is just a regional thing though, looks tasty anyway.
  
  Downvoted for being American
  
  And Americans call savoury scones "biscuits" even though they're not cooked twice.
  
  "Most people" are wrong. Terminology exists for a reason. You made a cottage pie, you just didn't know what you were making.
Man the name of the dish is so not the point of this community. I stand by Lemmy in present state is far worse than reddit for pedantic or toxic behavior.

It looks really good OP, nice job! I'd eat it regardless of what you called it.
- Agreed that people are getting too feisty up in here.
  
  But that said, I’m a big fan of making WHATEVER topped-with-potatoes pie out of leftovers, and I’m sure my wife and I have done it with things that would cause the purists to lose their damn minds. I think we’re gonna make one with leftover Ethiopian this week.
  
  And you're inviting me over for some?! Hell yeah!
- Thanks lol so many people butt hurt about the name . I'm pretty sure the frozen shepherds pie you can buy at the grocery store also doesn't have lamb . It was very good I ate the whole thing and was super full .
  
  This is correct about the frozen stuff. It's usually made with ground beef. Making it with steak (or lamb) sounds way better.
- This dish looks great!
  
  Also I totally agree with the Lemmy comment.
- I suspect there's a direct correlation between education level and urges to be pedantic. When schooling hammered vocabulary into your head and punished you for misusing it, vocabulary being misused becomes tougher to enjoy.
  
  Toxic though? You're not insulting or harassing someone, unless they're really thin-skinned.
I prefer the traditional recipe that uses actual shepherd, but they’re getting harder to find these days.
Cowherd's pie?
- Cottage pie where I'm from
  
  Exactly. Supermarkets sell both.
  
  Although strictly speaking the supermarket cottage pie is more likely to be horse than beef.
- Ranchers pie?
- Shepherd's Cow Pie.
Un pâté chinois in Québec
Yum!
Shepard's pie

Here's mine from Sunday.

You've viewed 51 comments.