what are the best and worst Halloween candy to receive?

Best: Reese’s

Worst: Circus Peanuts

I got eerily angry complaints from parents one Halloween after I gave out cotton candy "because it filled up too much space in their bags for something that would dissolve in their mouth all at once anyways as well as make them hyper as it's just sugar". Makes me wonder how they spent their evenings.

oh man pixie sticks are like summoning a demon
Man those parents don't know shit - you were a Hallowe'en hero

Best: Full size Snickers, Reese's Halloween editions

Worst: Candy Corn and Circus Peanuts

First thing I thought of when I saw the post, and your comment was the first I saw!

Best: Reese's, starbursts, Skittles

Worst: Those peanut butter chews wrapped in orange or black that have a weird soft but chunky feel that reminds me of something half digested. Anything healthy. Anything not candy (stickers, pencils, etc).

Glow bracelets go super fast in my neighborhood. They even take them off my skeletons. Of course we do candy too.
Came here to post unnamed peanut butter bullshit.

Like, our parents were supposed to look at our candy to make sure it wasn’t tampered with (urban legend), yet everybody looked at the unlabeled wrap job on those pieces of shit and was like “yeah, this def doesn’t contain a razor blade.”
I think they are actually molasses flavoured toffee if it's the ones I'm thinking of. Always left to the very last, only to be consumed in the more dire of candy draughts
Reese's are trash but the rest is on point. Personal opinion obviously

Best: drugs

Worst: also drugs

I remember rediscovering Hallowe'en as an adult. Totally different vibe except definitely still hedonistic af

Best: Subjective.

Worst: religous pamphlets proletizing the youth because the religous must target those without fully functioning brains lest their numbers dwindle.

I see no one has mentioned Swedish fish yet. Always felt they were so freaking waxy they tasted like nothing. Probably not the worst though.

I recently tried a "European" swedish fish by Kolsvart, and they are way better.
I'm sorry but propaganda does not technically count as candy.

To be fair I once got 5 dimes wrapped in a little black mesh thing. It was lame as hell, but they did make an effort so I didn't complain. But even back in the late 80s/early 90s, 50¢ wasn't really useful, even for a kid.
- It's candy for your soul, how about that?

Best: Good candy corn

Worst: Bad candy corn

There are tiers of candy corn?
- I think it just boils down to softness?

Best: full size Snickers bars

Worst: full size Snickers bars but you have peanut allergy

Permanently Deleted

That shit was my jam when I was a kid
I loved those.

I don't but a close friend does. he would trade away coconut for it
- That gave me the idea to toss in a coconut or two into bags this year. I'll reserve those for the "kids" that are obviously too old for this stuff.

Best: twix, 100grand, candy corn, sweet tarts

Worst: bottle caps, heath, unnamed hard candies, tootsie rolls

I have a buddy who's favorite is heath bars

He's a little different
I blocked out the existence of bottle caps

Best: kit-kats, twix, heath bar, and the wee chocolates dark/light/crunch mix assortment.

Worst: banana laffy taffy, smarties

Also I freaking love black licorice and my kids do too but would never, ever dare hand it out, absolutely a trick not a treat for most kids.

I also love black licorice. Did we just become best friends?
- Sir that is nasty

The dentist's house handed out toothbrushes. Which actually was really thoughtful and appreciated by the poorer parents

imagine the ruckus if he'd handed out something with fluoride in it
- Like toothpaste?

Worst is Necco wafers.

Best is Whoppers, then Sixlets.

Ha, I would take Necco over whoppers and sixlets any day. We should have been friends as kids; best candy trade partner ever.

Trick or treating isn’t so much of a thing in Australia, even though the idea of Halloween and dressing up has become more popular.

Anyway, no one has ever done it in our neighbourhood, but just in case I buy a bag of chupa chups in October in case anyone knocks on the door.

I once gave a single banana to a group of kids and told them to be sure to split it between them.

That was a massive improvement over the year before, where I had nothing at all.

It was extra sad because their parents only allowed them to go through the building they lived in, and it didn't have many people.

Thing is, halloween isn't really a thing there, plus I am absolutely terrible with dates.

When I was a kid my father handed out cans of soup.
- My MIL used to work for a dentist. One year he encouraged? required? the employees to hand out toothbrushes on Halloween. My hubby begged his mom not to do it, to just fib and tell her boss she had. But... she went through with it. They got egged that night & their pumpkin was smashed. She fucked around and found out.
- Your birthdays must have been memorable

If the reaction of the kids who come to my door is any indication the best is ring pops. You can sometimes hear kids shouting to other ones down the street "hey, this place has ring pops!"

Worst: those molasses toffees with the orange/white/black wrapper

Best: Butterfinger Worst: candy corn, circus peanuts

The best is almost always full size candy bars, though everyone's personal favorites are different.

As for the worst, people might rag on the orange and black peanut butter things, candy corn, or circus peanuts. I personally like them all and I feel most of the hate is memetic.

The real bad candy? Peppermints. Even worse and strange? Peppermint candy canes.

Sure, I like them in December, but seeing those mixed in with other candy is an insult and reminds you of Christmas creep. It's a breath mint. There might be one freakish kid who likes those hard minty disks of Christmas flavor around Halloween, but really, no one is excited about these restaurant give aways. Even hating on the candy you don't like is part of the Halloween experience, but peppermint just feels wrong in a trick or treat bag.

I wholeheartedly agree on the peppermint thing

Best: chocolate Worst: raisins

Best: Reese's peanut butter cups

Worst: Tootsie Rolls, they're just wax with a slightly sweet flavor

you don't look at wax and fantasize about chewing on it sometimes?
I love tootsie rolls. I’ll trade you.
- That's fair

Worst->Best

At least on the scale of what I'm handing out.

Had to scale it back this year only 43 lbs, probably only last about half the night.

What I don't understand about those garbage molasses candies is who buys them and why? At this point they've been the most hated candy for decades.

Best: King size candy bars

Worst: Those little rock-hard peanut butter taffy things in the black and orange wrappers.

I fucking love those things

MaryJanes. Should be outlawed by international convention.

Best: Twix

Worst: peanut butter kisses

Best: full size candy bars Worst: US Smarties.

Can't believe you're the only person I've seen that has said candy Tums

Worst: any kind of hard candy, yuck! Especially smarties, or those peppermint things. Oh and Tootsie Rolls and Tootsie pops.

Best: Any kind of chocolate

Permanently Deleted

Best: drugs

Worst: anything with coconut

Worst: anything with coconut.

We don't take kindly to folks like you in this here town. Coconut is awesome.
- I love coconut water, always keep a case on hand. But whatever they put in candy is gross to me. You can have my almond joys.