Uhh... yeah, people have gotten real fucking weird about dogs over the last twenty years. Like, i mostly stay out of it, but when was the last time you saw a dog that could heel. Like the dog's off leash running around having fun and someone yell' ps "skipper! Heel!" And the dog walks over and lays down beside them waiting for a command, or walks calmly next to them. You know, heel. It's the most basic, probably the most important command. I can't think of any time i've met a dog that could heel up since I was a kid. People have gotten real fucking weird about dogs. It's freaky. I try to stay out of it.
Huge numbers of dogs also have weird behavioral triggers with bikes, skateboards, and scooters. Will lunge at them as they go by. I was walking one of my friends' dogs because they were out of town and the fucker tried to straight up yeet himself into oncoming traffic because he saw a bicycle on the other side of the road. Had dogs try to lunge at me as I biked by many times. Why do these people even take them out on bike paths???
Right? They're territorial predators, and people just don't train or socialize them. Those leashes that are on a spring and the dog can just spool out line, that's not keeping your dog under control. idk, people are fucking goofy. And then they get goofy when you point out that their 40, 50lb predatory land mammal isn't safe to take outside. Not safe for the dog, not safe for bystanders, because they made no effort at all to train the animal. Like fuck off, dude, you're the one who couldn't be bothered to take your dog to puppy socialization and teach it to stay, you are the villain here.
Pets are a responsibility. If I had a fucking feral child everyone would call me a negligent parent. Same goes for pets. They might be inclined to cohabitation due to domestication but that doesn't mean you can take a hands-free approach.
people have gotten real fucking weird about dogs over the last twenty years
Yes, it's almost like people have become less financially stable and more socially isolated they've become attached to easily accessible sources of relationships and affection. It's no excuse to not train your dog, but people's relationship with their pets has fundamentally changed.
Every revolution ever has been started by a handful of weirdos in a niche group. We need better niche groups or weirdos if we ever want to get anything off the ground.
There's some very good points in that thread about people over othe valuing the lives of dogs over other people and being misanthropic, and replacement parenting with regards to "fur babies", but as usual on Reddit, it's buried under a ton of nonsense.
I've been rescuing stray dogs and cats my whole life without provocation, caring for animals is just a thing we humans with our constantly active empathetic and social instincts do. I'm also not saying those of you who don't "get" it aren't empathetic or social but you must be lying if you can't at least intellectually understand why people would enjoy it.
Edited to say that I do agree that there are def some hateful freaks out there who only like animals because animals don't talk back, but when my cat puts his little warm body in the crook of my arm I'm not thinking "wow you are so much more worthy of my love than a human being"
I think this might be a thing where because we're all chronically online, we're assuming this is a weird online take but it might actually just be a normal take but we're not normal enough to realize it's normal
Nah it's weird. And I think you're misunderstanding that clip the takeaway isn't that reactionaries like dogs and normal people don't Darius is sort of definitionally not normal, and he likes dogs anyways.
I definitely think OP has a point where reactionaries who don't have solidarity or feelings of connection and belonging with fellow humans are more likely to be weird dog people tho
Wasn't there some prank TV show from the 00's that literally genuinely did the dog-target schtick at a gun range. I remember that being an Obama era joke.
Yeah, as most struggle sessions do make some good points.
But then you have some guy proudly talking about his dad beating a dog with a stick and saying it was based cuz he's a POC. Like yes white people "luv my heckin doggo more than people" culture is cringe, counter jerking to it to the point you celebrate animal abuse is even more cringe.
People are increasingly alienated from their fellow humans, and as a defense against that alienation they are ascribing more and more importance to their companion animals. In some cases this reaches a point where it is harmful both to the person and the animal, as the person is unable to effectively care for the animal because they no longer recognize it as having the limitations and needs of an animal.
I think that's pretty much what I was saying but much better worded. People with poorly trained dogs because they over anthropromorphise them are a product of alienation and atomization.
I was joking, but as with most things it depends on the context. Blind loyalty is bad, yes, but so is an informed loyalty to a dishonorable cause or person(s).
The "best" ranked replies are all jokes (that I think are funny, like the "a cat posted this" image) or reasonable replies about how they like dogs or that your can't just call everything you don't like reactionary or that dogs that act out are usually socialized poorly.